Does a player have NHL upside if they are a forward that can’t score 1PPG in the USHL the second time they go through the draft? That would be my question.
Yes, I do believe there is NHL upside, even if it's not much more than a 4C. He's big, can get around the ice, and is competitive which is a good starting point for any player. I'm not too concerned about the stats with Fisher (or any player really). Whether he scored 40 points or 60 points in the USHL, his game in the NHL is going to be a north south player that's always on the puck and has a good enough shot to score the odd goal. If he had 4 more secondary assists this year, would that change your opinion of him?
He lacks the skill to play higher in the lineup, I'd agree with you there. But he has a lot of aspects you look for in a player to play a grind role. He has good habits, gets in on the forecheck, strong on the puck, and supports the puck well defensively.
At the end of the day though, odds are still against him. He's a 4th rounder for a reason and even then went a touch earlier than I would have looked at him. Not too many are going to make it from that range. I'd still take Fisher over some other players that may have scored more this past year but aren't that big, aren't that fast, don't have the blow you away skill to think they can play top 6 and can't play bottom 6.