At the 2003 Top Prospects Game I saw Bobby Clarke on the jumbo tron, realized I was sitting close to him so I went and asked for an autograph. He said "I don't have a pen". Two guys came up right behind me with pucks and a pen and asked him for his autograph. He asked them "aren't you two a bit old for this?". I asked if he could use their pen to sign my magazine and he obliged. Always got a kick out of that.
I was surprised how hardcore people are about there love of Don Cherry and getting his autograph. At the same game, I almost didn't get his autograph because several 40+ men crowded me out and refused to let me in when there was a bit of room to get an autograph.
Went to the prospect tournament the Leafs and 3 other teams are in when Schenn was drafted. Went down near the dressing room for autographs and asked him for an autograph and he said if we waited on the main floor he'd sign when he was done with post-game excercizes or whatever. We did and when he came up, as soon as he saw us he said "oh ****" or "**** sakes". He signed in an annoyed manner and left. Only time I ever had that happen at these rookie tournaments.
at the same tournament also got Erik Karlson , when he came out of the building I said "I think that's Karlson" to my friend and EK said "No, I'm not Erik Karlson" jokingly before walking over to us and signing our pucks for us. Definitely a better experience than Schenn.
I told Dan Bylsma he did a great job in Pittsburgh the summer after they won the cup first and he said "that's what I want my bosses to think!".
When I asked Tyler Seguin for an autgraph in his draft year he said "let me put my stuff on the bus and I'll come back and sign for you" which I thought for sure was one of those lines you get before a guy bails, but true to his word he came back. Was surprised because if a guy uses that line he's rarely coming back.
On the positive side, some guys who have really impressed me with how they conduct themselves with fans:
Jeff Skinner - visibly anxious but super polite, like Peter Parker or something
Brian Boucher - total professional, he gets it
Jay Harrison - legit cool guy, I've seen him park his car in pouring rain to go sign for fans and stand there having a long conversation while getting soaked. Plus, he's a guy you'd want to have a beer with.
Eddie Lack - just a nice, funny guy who clearly enjoys people
Jaccob Slavin - sort of an All American personality, he obviously takes his influence on fans seriously.
As a Kitchener Ranger I got his autograph, as I've seen a couple times, he will sign your shoe upon request.