dotcommunism
Moderator
- Aug 16, 2007
- 5,194
- 3,394
Player Discussion Evander Kane - Part 4
- Thread starter dotcommunism
- Start date
How timely. A clean slate after his latest charges were dropped with an opportunity for a new start.
I'm a big fan of Kane. Love his style of play. He never stops, is always a threat and he seemed to take less shots at bad angles this year. I have not heard of locker room discord so can I assume everything is okay there? It does appear that he gets along with his teammates - but what do I know.
At this point, I'd be fine if they kept him, assuming he will sign with Buffalo after this year. If not, the next best thing is rental at the trade deadline.
I'd also be happy if they could send him somewhere as part of a trade to secure a top 4 defenceman.
There are a few options with him and I'm sure he'll be at or near the top of what the new GM needs to consider.
I'm a big fan of Kane. Love his style of play. He never stops, is always a threat and he seemed to take less shots at bad angles this year. I have not heard of locker room discord so can I assume everything is okay there? It does appear that he gets along with his teammates - but what do I know.
At this point, I'd be fine if they kept him, assuming he will sign with Buffalo after this year. If not, the next best thing is rental at the trade deadline.
I'd also be happy if they could send him somewhere as part of a trade to secure a top 4 defenceman.
There are a few options with him and I'm sure he'll be at or near the top of what the new GM needs to consider.
La Cosa Nostra
Caporegime
- Jun 25, 2009
- 14,110
- 2,379
If the Sabres add a Kane replacement in free agency like Oshie then I am all for moving Kane for a dman (not Tanev, I want a similar aged dman for Kane, along with one who won't miss 15+ games a season). I would target Brodin for Kane+. The Wild need a retool if they want to get past the first round. They had 6 players total score goals this post season. That's not going to cut it. Kanes game is literally bred for playoff hockey. Nino had a terrible post season, I think Kane would be a good addition to the Wild on a line with Nino. I know Brodin misses his fair share of games but I feel quite confident that over the next 3 seasons that Brodin will end up playing more games then Tanev will.
So if the Sabres can find a top 6 replacement for Kane who can come in and replace the 25 goals Kane provides then I'm down with moving Kane.
If there aren't any quality offers for Kane and he is open to a fair extension then I also would be happy with extending Kane granted that we improve the D. $5.75 mil x 5-6 years.
So if the Sabres can find a top 6 replacement for Kane who can come in and replace the 25 goals Kane provides then I'm down with moving Kane.
If there aren't any quality offers for Kane and he is open to a fair extension then I also would be happy with extending Kane granted that we improve the D. $5.75 mil x 5-6 years.
JLewyB
Registered User
Does Kane fit any of the Pegula qualities he's looking for? I think he's gone if it was up to Pegula which it kinda is up to him.
The trade rumors aren't really surprising, especially in light of the Pegula's talk about "Good Character" in the Bills/Sabres pressers.
If I was a betting man, I'd say Kane is likely gone. The question is, what is the return. I think it'll be more of a "hockey deal" rather than let's say "picks/prospects".
Jim Bob
RIP RJ
Given the cap being and not a lot of teams having a ton of space, I think the hockey trade route is the most likely strictly because the other team will likely want to send a contract back in the deal.
Vegas would be the most obvious team that could give up futures, yet I can't see them giving up their first ever first rounder for EK. So, there is that, too.
a hockey trade...
Look for a Defensemen with 1 year left before UFA
I am not saying these are realistic targets, only that they match the criteria of a "hockey trade":
Boston - Chara
Detroit - Green
Montreal - Emelin
Tampa - Garrison
Columbus - J.Johnson
New Jersey - J.Moore
NY Islanders - Hickey
Pitt - I.Cole
Colorado - Beauchemin
Dallas - Hamhuis
WPG - Enstrom
Ana - Stoner, Fowler
LA - McNabb , Greene
SJ - Vlasic
VAN - Sbisa
Look for a Defensemen with 1 year left before UFA
I am not saying these are realistic targets, only that they match the criteria of a "hockey trade":
Boston - Chara
Detroit - Green
Montreal - Emelin
Tampa - Garrison
Columbus - J.Johnson
New Jersey - J.Moore
NY Islanders - Hickey
Pitt - I.Cole
Colorado - Beauchemin
Dallas - Hamhuis
WPG - Enstrom
Ana - Stoner, Fowler
LA - McNabb , Greene
SJ - Vlasic
VAN - Sbisa
Jack Johnson???
Maybe even through a trade with Vegas. Hypothetically Vegas selects Johnson from Columbus (maybe Vegas even gets a pick in exchange because it would help out Columbus' cap situation and allows them to keep Anderson/Karlsson/Korpisalo), then trades Johnson to Buffalo in exchange for Kane. Both have one year, similar cap hits, Kane is almost 5years younger.
I'd take Stoner with Fowler and hope that's enough incentive, with a potential add to Kane. But ideally Brodin is the D-man that would help the most.
yea. I'd entertain that...
I think the question is, would you prefer the non-hockey trade... the deadline rental value... a 2nd rounder...
Or would you prefer 1 year of a solid defensemen (with the potential to re-sign, if the fit is right).
I don't think the Sabres would be looking for another player with one year remaining before UFA who they have to quickly decide whether to sign long-term. I wonder if Botterill is looking to make a trade similar to the Neal/Hornqvist trade where most thought the Pens lost the deal on paper, but they acquired a player who was a much better fit for what the Pens wanted to do. That supposed "lesser" player would also have some term left on a deal.
LA does make a lot of sense for Kane. It's the type of city he wants. Gets him out of a fishbowl hockey market. They seem to value Kane's positive attributes. I'm thinking something around Martinez or Forbort, with small adds on either side.
LA does make a lot of sense for Kane. It's the type of city he wants. Gets him out of a fishbowl hockey market. They seem to value Kane's positive attributes. I'm thinking something around Martinez or Forbort, with small adds on either side.
La Cosa Nostra
Caporegime
- Jun 25, 2009
- 14,110
- 2,379
Yeah I definitely see LA as a feasible landing spot, they had a huge thing for Lucic and totally overpaid for him, so why wouldn't they want a far younger player who plays a similiar style game?
I also am calling it now, the return we get will be far better then what people are throwing around.
I also am calling it now, the return we get will be far better then what people are throwing around.
Some people have thrown around Tanev... the return will be nowhere close to that good.
You'd want Forbort? Lacks foot speed... can't carry the puck... just seems like a name acquisition (former 1st rounder), more than a "fit" acquisition
With Martinez, i think there are other avenues to acquire similar defensemen (CDH).
I agree, on paper, one of those guys is probably what LA is offering...
I didn't say anything about wanting Forbort. I just used him as an example of a lesser name on LA. I think certain people would ***** about Alec Martinez not being enough value for Kane, too.
Botterill walks into the LA GM's office
"I need a good return for Kane"
Rob Blake reaches up on his shelf for assets, pulls down a 1st round pick
"Perhaps this will please you. But, beware, it comes with a curse!"
Botterill: "That's bad"
Blake "It also comes with a free Forbort"
Botterill: "That's good!"
Blake: "Forbort is also cursed"
Botterill: "That's bad!"
Blake: "Forbort was a 1st round draft pick though"
Botterill "That's good!"
Blake: "Forbort lacks footspeed and has a low corsi number despite low QoC ratings"
Botterill: ::stares blankly::
Blake: "That's bad"
Botterill: "Can I go now?"
Sabre the Win
Joke of a Franchise
- Jun 27, 2013
- 12,946
- 5,557
Yeah. When the Sabres find themselves without Josh Gorges, Muzzin will be able to step right into the role of 30-something, inadequate, overpaid, diminishing asset.
Last edited:
brian_griffin
"Eric Cartman?"
Agree with both your thinking.
As to Jame's question, which way does Botterill lean?
How bullish is Botts that he can clone the Pen defense or some viable Sabre alternative via the "bargain bin / diamond in the rough" approach?
Sabres need a top-4 LHD NHL caliber d-man. The other NHL-caliber depth RHD (the Franson re-signed option, or similar), is the one I'm confident Botterill can swing somehow.
The real question, as Jim Bob notes, is, will it take the expansion draft, or fear of the expansion draft, to shake something loose and make it happen before the summer UFA date or not?
If I'm the GM, for the LHD gap in the lineup, if I feel I have a young, cheap, diamond-in-the-rough solution, but I don't know if that player will be able to fulfill that role immediately out of the gate in October / November, then I pursue the hockey trade of the type Jame/dkollidas noted.
I'd do a Kane plus M.Foligno for Jack Johnson and a CBJ LW prospect.
Captain Holt
Fun? I was never fun! You take that back
Revelate
Registered User
- Apr 10, 2011
- 2,500
- 877
I'm not getting this analogy. Gorges is Gorges because he can't skate at an NHL level anymore. He was never anywhere near the skater Muzzin is.
Husko
Registered User
That might be a somewhat valid comparison if we were talking Martinez. But Muzzin is really in a different stratosphere from Georges. Unless Muzzin has to have his knee reconstructed like Georges I'm not too worried.
