I think they'll likely both be paid 'too much'.
The considerations have to be:
- Team need
- Potential longevity
- How 'too much'
The Jets organizationally have no one who's going to touch replacing Pionk in the near future, in their contending window. A top 4 RHD with proven offensive production is going to be difficult to acquire. A career 60 point 2nd line winger is a lot easier to replace. We also have players in the org who have the potential to do that, but admittedly no one who will likely just step in and do it. Then you have to consider what the Jets need NOW which are guys who perform in the playoffs. Pretty much all of the Jets have something to prove here but at least Pionk has shown he can do it.
Ehlers is often injured and his game revolves around his speed. He's pretty likely to underperform his contract and could end up a buyout. Pionk has been injured recently too, but probably has a bit of an edge here.
No idea which player would be more overpaid, but it might be Pionk wth the premium on top 4 RHD.
I think your statement is more based on emotional attachment than reality for the org.