I have no counter argument because I'm not arguing anything. You're the one arguing with yourself.
Also to answer your re-signing Getzlaf question. We can't extend him right now. That would need to happen next season.If you're going to try and pass of your opinions as "facts" maybe try and get actual facts correct. And two, if his quality of play next season is still easily top 6 quality (which it is right now) then yeah. Go the Thornton route, re-sign him for 1-2 year deals so he can mentor the young players while they get ready to take over his spot. The ironic thing is how you're calling him a head ache when he's still our best offensive player by far, and a player you repeatedly tried to sell off on the trade forums while boasting how great he is.
What better conversations? The ones where non-Ducks fans tell you how ridiculous some of your opinions are? Like how Ottawa should trade us the Sharks 1st round pick because we deserve it? I see most of your conversations on there end up just like here with you arguing your opinions as "fact" without any justifiable reason. And when provided actual evidence that counter your arguments; you ignore it, misconstrued the facts to support your opinions, or change the topic.
Also it's hilarious you seem to completely ignore the actual stats I brought up for Getz, and your flip flopping statements; but apparently that's not a real argument or debate?