Proposal: Ducks/Avs/Isles

[Zegs2sendhelp]

So the Avs give up a first and take on a higher cap hit for a player that has been one of the worst starters in the league the past five seasons and probably isn't any better than Georgiev?

Gross.

Okay shane lets not get carried away

Gibson sitting at a 915 Save percentage
Georgiev is at 874

Id say Colorado has a much better roster/defense than anaheim.

Colorado gives up 25.6 shots a game
Anaheim gives up league worse 34 per game

Gibson is a significant upgrade on Georgiev... no matter how much you hate him.

 

[John Mandalorian]

Okay shane lets not get carried away

Gibson sitting at a 915 Save percentage
Georgiev is at 874

Id say Colorado has a much better roster/defense than anaheim.

Colorado gives up 25.6 shots a game
Anaheim gives up league worse 34 per game

Gibson is a significant upgrade on Georgiev... no matter how much you hate him.

Now consider that Gibson hasn’t been over .910 since 2019 in spite of having a cap hit that almost doubles Georgiev’s.

 

[PAZ]

Okay shane lets not get carried away

Gibson sitting at a 915 Save percentage
Georgiev is at 874

Id say Colorado has a much better roster/defense than anaheim.

Colorado gives up 25.6 shots a game
Anaheim gives up league worse 34 per game

Gibson is a significant upgrade on Georgiev... no matter how much you hate him.

Lets wait until more than 4 a game sample size, ya?

At least Georgiev is only 1 year removed from is .919 SV% season. The last time Gibson was anywhere near that was in 2018-19. Somehow Gibson had a worse SV% than George last year too.

Bad team vs good team argument, lost motivation, etc. End of the day Gibson's track record the past 5 years doesn't indicate he'd be a significant upgrade on Georgiev. He could be and there is an argument for it which is why a 1st/conditional 1st is being discussed, but it's by no means a guarantee.

 

[Shane Diesel]

Okay shane lets not get carried away

Gibson sitting at a 915 Save percentage
Georgiev is at 874

Over the past five seasons combined Georgiev has a higher SV% than Gibson.

NHL Stats

The official source for NHL Stats including skaters, goalies, teams stats and more.

www.nhl.com

The fact you're making your argument based on four games is highly telling, though.

Id say Colorado has a much better roster/defense than anaheim.

Colorado gives up 25.6 shots a game
Anaheim gives up league worse 34 per game

Gibson is a significant upgrade on Georgiev... no matter how much you hate him.

If you want to take the skaters out of it the stats don't get any better for Gibson, but I know you dismiss GSAx completely.

 

[Pierce Hawthorne]

Seems like way too steep of a price to pay for the Avs. We aren't even getting Gibson at 50% retention either?

Easy pass. Make it 50% retention and take out the 3rd, then I'd consider it. Although even then I think a 1st outright is steep.

What would be more reasonable IMO would be like a 2026 2nd that becomes a 1st if Gibson plays x number of games over the next 2 years. Say 50 games total over the next two years.