I agree that Dougie’s a complimentary player in the sense that you need to have a particular kind of partner for him if you want him to thrive against top competition. But that’s not as much of a negative as it sounds at face value. I think of guys like Karlsson and Slavin (to take two extreme opposites) who are really elite players but are not do-everything types.
When the Canes had both Hamilton and Slavin, it was a case of pairing two guys who each need a particular kind of partner to maximize their skills. And they were, if not the very best pairing in the league, at least in contention for the best on any given night. How could that put them individually at a lower tier than a guy who is not widely seen as a desirable #1D at all?
Well it wouldn't be that alone that gives me cause to rate Weegar as the better dman than Hamilton. Just one factor.
Let's just go over the various attributes one looks for in a top pairing defenseman
Offense - Clear edge to Hamilton, although not as big a gap as you'd think. Weegar for the first time in his career started getting significant PP time last season after Hanifin was traded and performed well there. Even strength production is fairly close(DH 0.4 career EV ppg, MW 0.38 career EV ppg). Both have great shots, Dougie shoots more, I think Weegs has a touch more creativity as a playmaker.
Defense - Clear edge to Weegar, although again not quite as big a gap as you'd think. Both guys can get a little lackadaisical defensively, both guys can make some odd braindead mistakes, Weegar more physical and a more active stick. Better takeaways, hits, and blocks per 82 for Mackenzie.
Skating - Used to be Dougie, probably still has an edge top speed wise but the injuries have definitely affected his agility and especially his pivots. Would rate this more or less even, Weegs has the better 4 direction movement, Hamilton still smoother North-South.
Physicality - Clear edge to Weegar, Dougie lays the odd hit and can box out but not really a big part of his game. Weegs very tough on fwds on the boards and in the slot. Will light somebody up every 3rd or 4th game.
Transition - Not sure there's all that much of a clear edge here, both are good in transition.
Weegs has some of the best transition numbers for any defenseman in the last 5 years both defending and creating rush chances so I'll give him the decision on this one.
Intangibles/Leadership - Got to give this to Weegs too. I never really bought all the Dougie Museum drama, I'm sure he's just fine in a locker room and a good guy. Judging from what I see on the ice I dunno if I've ever seen him elevate or find that next level of intensity that could have made him a great all around #1. Seems like he's happy to quietly play his minutes, pickup his points, collect his cheque, and carry on. Weegs steps in to defend his teammates, plays with real emotion, and can elevate when needed to. Off the ice Dougie never did much media or struck me as a positive influence on young players like Weegar does. Maybe that's unfair but that was my read on it.
I like my top pairing dmen to be guys you can put out there in all situations. Call it personal preference but I prefer Weegar's all around qualities to Hamilton's. Not a huge margin or anything, but considering he's younger and quite a bit cheaper as well I agree with the results of the poll. Lot less tread on the tires for Weegar too, Dougie has now only played over 65 games once since 2019.