Beukeboom Fan
Registered User
Just in general - trying to apply the same "bright lines" like you have with no regard for things like era, team, and health is going into the situation with blinders. Because per your guidelines, you would say that Bernie Nichols is more qualified for the HOF'er than a guy like Marian Gaborik.no.
Here is some of my criteria
1) 50 goal seasons? No
2) 100 pts seasons? Non
3) 500 goals/1000pts? No
4) Any hardware? No
While he won the cup with LA--he was brought in at the 11th hour to join the team.
For me he is the hall of very good.