Were people this mad when we signed both Volchenkov and Tallinder in 2010? One of them for $600k less than Clowe and for one more year, and Tallinder to a so so contract? Especially with a lower cap ceiling, and having trouble to get under the ceiling. I never liked either of those deals, but would have been okay with one of them.
I'll take a forward who puts up points over a stay at home defenseman with close to the same terms. I'd do it every time.
I remember being tentatively excited. Thought the term was going to be an issue with Volchenkov, but I was excited about the hitting ability.
The biggest issue with signing Tallinder and Volchenkov that year was that our defense badly needed mobility, speed and creativity from the back end. I'm assuming Lou tried to get a true offensive d-man, but once he failed, he just plugged in UFAs he figured would be reliable, if not puck-movers.
The Ryder contract is a slam-dunk. With Clowe, if his brains get fried, he's on LTIR. If he's slow and useless but healthy, well, maybe one day the Islanders will need to reach the cap floor again.