Prospects are always hit or miss regardless how fans view the development process our organization has. But this isn't James Hagen vs Gabe Perrault, this becomes are two Gabe Perrault's/James Hagen's better than one? We may have lucked out with grabbing Gabe later in the first round but that isn't always the case.
When you look at the pipeline, this team is not a top 10 prospect pool team anymore, they clearly need as many good pieces as possible, especially when you view where our core players are at. Swinging for home runs in the draft might not work out, but I do think we need higher end talent in our system, and drafting from the wild card spot - first round elimination doesn't help.