monitoring_string = "358c248ada348a047a4b9bb27a146148"
D Radim Mrtka - Seattle Thunderbirds, WHL (Draft 2025) | Page 5 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League
  • Xenforo Cloud upgraded our forum to XenForo version 2.3.4. This update has created styling issues to our current templates, this is just a temporary look. We will continue to work on clearing up these issues for the next few days and restore the site to it's more familiar look, but please report any other issues you may experience so we can look into. Thanks for your patience and understanding.

D Radim Mrtka - Seattle Thunderbirds, WHL (Draft 2025)

Briser la glace said:
That's what makes scouting so chaotic: we see two different players 😅 And it's not to have an argument or try to prove anything, I just find interesting to compare our observations that clearly don't go in the same direction. In the 7 full games I've watched and tracked of Mrtka, he was struggling under pressure and panicked a lot with the puck. I recognize he has a decent mobility, but I've never seen a "phenomenal" one with him. I like his four-way mobility, but he does not seem as fluid as Silayev or Simashev overall. His strides are short and choppy. His balance, pivots and backward skating were also an issue in some of my viewings. There were some "high-end" flashes, but the red flags were more frequent in the games I've watched.

If Mrtka has a phenomenal mobility, how would rate other big-bodied mobile D's such as Fiddler, Wang and Bedkowski? I'm just curious, because to me they are better skaters than Mrtka 🙂

And, once again, I think he's going to get drafted early, I think we all agree on this.
Click to expand...
I felt that Mrtka’s game was difficult to assess overall in Czechia but I always liked his mobility. In his most recent games in Seattle, I’ve liked him a lot, including his game tonight. I’ve seen multiple instances when faced with pressure, he responds with patience and confidence in his ability to move the puck and utilize his mobility to maintain puck possession. Along with that, he’s put in all situations. First PK and PP. I’m sure the transition to NA is causing some inconsistencies in his play, but the ability is certainly there. I won’t die on a hill defending this though as I may have just seen good games or noticed good moments as opposed to bad.

You’ve described his skating as choppy, however I think due to his size his stride may just seem a bit awkward. His ability to get around the ice is really impressive to me. I feel like Fiddler is certainly not in the same category in regard to overall mobility and certainly not straight line speed. However, I think the overall dexterity and agility of Mrtka along with his massive frame is the most appealing factor in his game. I also feel like his two-way game is definitely appealing with his puck distribution still maybe being a bit underrated.

Comparing Mrtka to Wang at this point is difficult because Wang is a much longer term project in my eyes. Mrtka has played at a much higher level of competition and is certainly more refined. Blake Fiddler is a really good defensive defender but I do question his offensive upside despite his early offensive numbers. I have not seen enough of David Bedkowski to form a meaningful opinion.

I have to agree that Dmitri Simashev’s mobility, without a doubt, is more impressive.
 
I agree with @Briser la glace on this.

Think he’s an NHL’er and potentially a good one, but I think he’s a DFD-only.

Keep in mind for his offensive ability that he’s basically only played on teams (except for Extraliga) where they’d give him good offensive situations because he’s needed to be that for teams that don’t have many draft picks.

There are pros and cons to every type of player and what teams and leagues they play in, but one of the things that probably looks a little rosy for someone like him is the offensive contributions.
 
Pavel Buchnevich said:
I agree with @Briser la glace on this.

Think he’s an NHL’er and potentially a good one, but I think he’s a DFD-only.

Keep in mind for his offensive ability that he’s basically only played on teams (except for Extraliga) where they’d give him good offensive situations because he’s needed to be that for teams that don’t have many draft picks.

There are pros and cons to every type of player and what teams and leagues they play in, but one of the things that probably looks a little rosy for someone like him is the offensive contributions.
Click to expand...
Agree I see him also more as defensive D, but a potential stable NHLer and thats what we need the most as czechs tbh. We are not at the position to excpect to spit out Cale Makar every other year lol, but we need to at least put those 6 freakin stable NHL defenders together ffs lol.
 
Another point last night. 6 points in last 6 games!

Mid first rounder
Future NHLer

Not Makar

Using giants
Better than Sustr
Worse than Chara

Maybe a Tyler Myers type career.. he's over 1000GP and has over 350 points. I'd like to think he has a higher ceiling but Myer himself was drafted around the same spot Mrtka should go. He was 12th. I think Radim is in 13th to 20th spot.

I hope we can all agree on this.lol
 
Czechboy said:
Another point last night. 6 points in last 6 games!

Mid first rounder
Future NHLer

Not Makar

Using giants
Better than Sustr
Worse than Chara

Maybe a Tyler Myers type career.. he's over 1000GP and has over 350 points. I'd like to think he has a higher ceiling but Myer himself was drafted around the same spot Mrtka should go. He was 12th. I think Radim is in 13th to 20th spot.

I hope we can all agree on this.lol
Click to expand...
Yup :-)
 
I think he’s closer to a TWD than a pure DFD tbh. Yes he doesn’t have the natural flashy puck skills, but i really think he's at least average at that. I've seen some flashes of skills that were surprising to me fos his size, so i'm not willing to say he has nothing in that part of the game. He's smart both ways of the ice and i believe he has the vision to have an impact offensively and in transition plays someday at the pro level. I feel you can see that he wants to make a difference when he has the puck on his stick, you can feel the intentions are there which is very positive to me. The ''want'' in his game is something you simply can't teach. He can activate and join the rush too. I've seen some DZ exits that were simply great, not just for his size but for defensemen in general showing great patience and poise. I can admit his game in Czechia was a bit underwhelming when i watched him, but absolutely loved him at the Hlinka and i like what i see in Seattle so far.

Good brain and nice compete level, he will only get better. Very good defensive habits, has the physical tools. I think now he's finally in a good place to improve his game. He's in my top 15 and I'd bet that NHL teams are all over him. Like i said last week, one of my favorites this year.
 
gothegr8 said:
I think he’s closer to a TWD than a pure DFD tbh. Yes he doesn’t have the natural flashy puck skills, but i really think he's at least average at that. I've seen some flashes of skills that were surprising to me fos his size, so i'm not willing to say he has nothing in that part of the game. He's smart both ways of the ice and i believe he has the vision to have an impact offensively and in transition plays someday at the pro level. I feel you can see that he wants to make a difference when he has the puck on his stick, you can feel the intentions are there which is very positive to me. The ''want'' in his game is something you simply can't teach. He can activate and join the rush too. I've seen some DZ exits that were simply great, not just for his size but for defensemen in general showing great patience and poise. I can admit his game in Czechia was a bit underwhelming when i watched him, but absolutely loved him at the Hlinka and i like what i see in Seattle so far.

Good brain and nice compete level, he will only get better. Very good defensive habits, has the physical tools. I think now he's finally in a good place to improve his game. He's in my top 15 and I'd bet that NHL teams are all over him. Like i said last week, one of my favorites this year.
Click to expand...
Yeah, calling him a pure defensive D right now is dumb. He’s shown he’s got some skill and it’s not unusual for big guys to take a while for their offensive upside and puck skills to come out. Seider, Jiricek, Bichsel come to mind.
 
Czechboy said:
Another point last night. 6 points in last 6 games!

Mid first rounder
Future NHLer

Not Makar

Using giants
Better than Sustr
Worse than Chara

Maybe a Tyler Myers type career.. he's over 1000GP and has over 350 points. I'd like to think he has a higher ceiling but Myer himself was drafted around the same spot Mrtka should go. He was 12th. I think Radim is in 13th to 20th spot.

I hope we can all agree on this.lol
Click to expand...
Yor mum is Tyler Myers, if he is better Jordán it´s a major win for czech hockey and the nation as a whole.
 
pgfan66 said:
Yeah, calling him a pure defensive D right now is dumb. He’s shown he’s got some skill and it’s not unusual for big guys to take a while for their offensive upside and puck skills to come out. Seider, Jiricek, Bichsel come to mind.
Click to expand...
Oh stop, don’t casually throw Seider into that discussion.

He had it right away and he’s not the comparable with Mrtka.

Jiricek is the opposite type of player where he’s always had the offensive ability. Skating is his biggest problem. Bichsel has scored a little in the AHL, but I don’t know how that proves he projects as a real scorer in the NHL.
 
Looks great on small ice. Really closes fast. Blink and all the open ice is gone. He’s so long and so fast and so fluid. Must be unbelievably frustrating to play against him. It’s like he’s got a 13ft stick.
 
He kinda reminds me of Parayko in the 2 games I've seen of his so far. Haven't really seen his shot much yet but good skater although not the most fluid but that's normal for guys his size still filling out. Solid puck skills and makes the right read most of the time, isn't afraid of contact. would say he goes somewhere in the teens atm
 
I agree he has some runway to become a TWD and he has very nice offensive flashes, I just don't know yet if these flashes will really translate to the NHL. But he does like to support the offence, he does not have a "stay-at-home" mindset.

Nobody seems to agree on his skating, and I think that's what will make the difference between a Top-4 potential or a bottom-pairing shutdown D.

I agree he sometimes look good :




but he also often looks like this, which is definitely not fluid and not Top-4 calibre imo... It seems especially bad when he has the puck and has no clear plan in mind.




wdyt?
 
Briser la glace said:
I agree he has some runway to become a TWD and he has very nice offensive flashes, I just don't know yet if these flashes will really translate to the NHL. But he does like to support the offence, he does not have a "stay-at-home" mindset.

Nobody seems to agree on his skating, and I think that's what will make the difference between a Top-4 potential or a bottom-pairing shutdown D.

I agree he sometimes look good :

View attachment 946449


but he also often looks like this, which is definitely not fluid and not Top-4 calibre imo... It seems especially bad when he has the puck and has no clear plan in mind.

View attachment 946442


wdyt?
Click to expand...
how is that clip supposed to make Mrtka look bad? He made a great read to jump up looking for a pass but his teammate made a dumb move. Sure a backhand saucer isn't easy but if the teammate makes that move in behind 34 Mrtka walks into the high slot wide open for a high danger chance for a likely goal. Ends up recovering the bad pass and uses body to shield from pressure before moving to his d partner
 
landy92mack29 said:
how is that clip supposed to make Mrtka look bad? He made a great read to jump up looking for a pass but his teammate made a dumb move. Sure a backhand saucer isn't easy but if the teammate makes that move in behind 34 Mrtka walks into the high slot wide open for a high danger chance for a likely goal. Ends up recovering the bad pass and uses body to shield from pressure before moving to his d partner
Click to expand...
I never said it was a bad play, I was talking about his skating. If you say he looks like a fluid skater in the second clip, well, we don't agree on what a fluid skater should look like, but that's fine, we all have our opinions and I respect yours as long as you respect mine :)
 
I don't see how Mrtka looks bad on that clip. He is on a crap Seattle team and already a point a game. He just got to North America like 15 minutes ago. Does he even speak English?

So far he has been incredible when you really think and factor in everything.

New Jersey should try and get him and pair him one day with Silayev.

You want to score on that pairing?

F&^* around and find out.
 
VictoriaJetsFan said:
I don't see how Mrtka looks bad on that clip. He is on a crap Seattle team and already a point a game. He just got to North America like 15 minutes ago. Does he even speak English?

So far he has been incredible when you really think and factor in everything.

New Jersey should try and get him and pair him one day with Silayev.

You want to score on that pairing?

F&^* around and find out.
Click to expand...
Idk, I guess I'm wrong and don't have a good read on him, that happens 🤷‍♂️ I'll go watch more games..
 
Pavel Buchnevich said:
Oh stop, don’t casually throw Seider into that discussion.

He had it right away and he’s not the comparable with Mrtka.

Jiricek is the opposite type of player where he’s always had the offensive ability. Skating is his biggest problem. Bichsel has scored a little in the AHL, but I don’t know how that proves he projects as a real scorer in the NHL.
Click to expand...
We seem to have different definitions of two-way D then. I don’t need a two-way D to be “a real scorer”.

And agree to disagree then. Seider really didn’t have much offense in him when he made the jump from low-level junior to pro. Jiricek was very similar in that he stood out early as an aggressive, physical defensive player who was able to incorporate more and more skill and deception into his puck play post-draft.
 
Bubbles said:
He's literally the only decent T-birds d-man left after Mynio got traded. Last couple of games I watched he seemed to never leave the ice.
Click to expand...
Excellent. Play the living shit out of him and hopefully he's available for U18. I've got him pegged around 16 in round 1. Curious how it ends. I feel like he may rise a little.
 
Czechboy said:
Excellent. Play the living shit out of him and hopefully he's available for U18. I've got him pegged around 16 in round 1. Curious how it ends. I feel like he may rise a little.
Click to expand...
6'6", skates well, right-handed, handles the puck well, solid IQ. I wouldn't be shocked if he went top-10 simply because solid RHD with size are extremely rare. Reinbacher-lite.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top
-->->