Value of: Cole Caufield or Nick Robertson

[DomBarr]

Both are NHL ready. Caufield has a bit more NHL experience by 4 games and Robertson is a bit bigger.

In their final years of junior, Caufield had 30 goals in 31 games at the university of Wisconsin. Robertson had 55 goals in 46 games with the Peterborough Petes and has a couple more years of pro. They are the same age.
Caufield has a better shot and Robertson is a great skater.

Who do you think has the bigger upside. Very similar players. Who would you want on your team?

I am just going to stay out of a thread where posters are forced to tell Leaf fans that Robertson comes in second to Caufield in this 2 player thread.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Still Robertson for me

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

I mean you coulda just done

matthews vs Suzuki

 

[Arthur Morgan]

Too early

 

[Arthur Morgan]

and Id take Caufield

 

[Digitalbooya]

Both are NHL ready. Caufield has a bit more NHL experience by 4 games and Robertson is a bit bigger.

In their final years of junior, Caufield had 30 goals in 31 games at the university of Wisconsin. Robertson had 55 goals in 46 games with the Peterborough Petes and has a couple more years of pro. They are the same age.
Caufield has a better shot and Robertson is a great skater.

Who do you think has the bigger upside. Very similar players. Who would you want on your team?

It's so weird calling college hockey "junior" hockey.

Caufield was the best player in college hockey. 30 goals was 11 more goals then the guy in second place.

I'll take Caufield easily here.

 

[Copenhagen91]

Anyone who thinks it’s Robertson. Is wrong.

 

[NMacrules]

In before the fighting and lock happens.

Glad you made it just in time...to read the other 2 pages.

 

[TT1]

lol

 

[WetcoastOrca]

Robertson is a fine prospect. Caufield is at another level though.

 

[Junohockeyfan]

Is Robertson even NHL ready? lol

 

[Michoulicious]

I mean it's caufield isn't it? Is anyone going to seriously debate this?

Made a poll about them a year ago and IIRC Robertson won.

Tells you all you need to know lol

 

[Connor McConnor]

Compare him to Jason, the better brother, and this is a more legit debate.

 

[ole ole]

Both are NHL ready. Caufield has a bit more NHL experience by 4 games and Robertson is a bit bigger.

In their final years of junior, Caufield had 30 goals in 31 games at the university of Wisconsin. Robertson had 55 goals in 46 games with the Peterborough Petes and has a couple more years of pro. They are the same age.
Caufield has a better shot and Robertson is a great skater.

Who do you think has the bigger upside. Very similar players. Who would you want on your team?

Nick who?

 

[DingDongCharlie]

I am just going to stay out of a thread where posters are forced to tell Leaf fans that Robertson comes in second to Caufield in this 2 player thread.

Im glad you came in his thread and commented that you wouldn’t be commenting. Oh these boards!!!

 

[DomBarr]

I really tried to just not say anything but then I just couldnt resist..

 

[McSuper]

Both are NHL ready. Caufield has a bit more NHL experience by 4 games and Robertson is a bit bigger.

In their final years of junior, Caufield had 30 goals in 31 games at the university of Wisconsin. Robertson had 55 goals in 46 games with the Peterborough Petes and has a couple more years of pro. They are the same age.
Caufield has a better shot and Robertson is a great skater.

Who do you think has the bigger upside. Very similar players. Who would you want on your team?

Is this a real question ? Take it is a Leafs fan that posted this because there way a Montreal would compare Caufield to a much lower tier prospect . I would take Caufield 10 times out of 10

 

[abo9]

This has to be a troll, "4 more NHL games of experience"? "Not proven anything"?

Caufield was a key piece in Montreal's playoff run to the Stanley Cup finals.

Anything could happen, but right now the answer is Caufield

 

[Grand Admiral Thrawn]

This is how you settle this real quick.

Both are available right now and you have to pick one... who do you take?

You're welcome!

 

[BenningHurtsMySoul]

Caufield means more to Montreal fans right now than Messier means to Rangers fans.

 

[Aashir Mallik]

Leafs fan, this is caufield

I expect caufield to peak at 30-35 Goals and 60-70 points

I expect Robertson to peak at 20-25 goals and 45-55 points

not exactly a fair comparison

it’s like comparing nylander and drouin….

 

[Blaine8797]

Both are NHL ready. Caufield has a bit more NHL experience by 4 games and Robertson is a bit bigger.

In their final years of junior, Caufield had 30 goals in 31 games at the university of Wisconsin. Robertson had 55 goals in 46 games with the Peterborough Petes and has a couple more years of pro. They are the same age.
Caufield has a better shot and Robertson is a great skater.

Who do you think has the bigger upside. Very similar players. Who would you want on your team?

Caufield I see as a first line player, I don’t believe the hype surrounding robertson in the slightest

 

[NMacrules]

Is this a real question ? Take it is a Leafs fan that posted this because there way a Montreal would compare Caufield to a much lower tier prospect . I would take Caufield 10 times out of 10

Nope, Colorado. Hence my avatar name is NMacrules. NMac is Nathan MacKinnon.

 

[Legend123]

Leafs fan, this is caufield

I expect caufield to peak at 30-35 Goals and 60-70 points

I expect Robertson to peak at 20-25 goals and 45-55 points

not exactly a fair comparison

it’s like comparing nylander and drouin….

there is hope for a lot more than that

 

[Guided by Veseys]

The same Caulfield that lit up the Vegas series like no leaf has done since I can remember?
Yeah, gonna go Robertson here. This is obviously a Taylor/Tyler situation.