I found and watched the Magee documentary and match. Enjoyable stuff. It cracks me up that apparently if you go to a barbecue at Bret Hart's house, Bret Hart matches are on in the house. Waltman is enjoyable, which always surprises me even though he comes off well in podcasts. Harry Smith does a good Bret impression. Magee's tights are a few sizes too small. As for the match, it's pretty enjoyable. A classic example of hiding someone's flaws as well as possible and working with their strengths and it ends up around the upper limit of what I expected. It's more impressive if you've seen Magee's stuff with other top wrestlers, because he really is laughably bad outside of this match.
I think Magee is just a case of a guy completely lacking aptitude for something. He looks so awkward out there in other matches that even when he walks it looks weird. I'd guess that he pretty much never played a ball based sport and instead focused on bodybuilding, because his fluidity is so lacking. He may have more raw athleticism than a guy like Michaels or Styles but he's so lacking in movement, and the way he plays to the crowd is also pretty weird. Just the opposite of a natural.