Proposal: CHI - OTT: Reichel for Boucher

[Muffinalt]

Reichel is at a point where his likely remaining value is only as a reclamation project for another team that believes he's a better fit in their system/development group.

I think we are looking at a soonish trade of struggling prospect for struggling prospect.

Ottawa would you guys be interested? He has good connection with Stutzle obviously, can be a body in the NHL right now if we stretch it.

How is Boucher doing? I get he was way over drafted, but what's the opinion on his future now? Sorry haven't followed him closely so I might be off base value wise but I would like him in the Hawks prospect pool.

Click to read more...

 

[topseed]

Same nationality guarantees good connection? Reichel is trash, doesn't hold any value, probably back to Eisbaren Berlin real soon or Swizz league if he's being adventurous. Soft as a butter.

 

[HockeyVirus]

Somehow the Hawks badly lose that trade. Boucher is barely an AHL player

 

[Mrfenn92]

No thanks as a hawks fan

 

[jbeck5]

I think Reichel is the better player, but I say no.

I don't see either being an impact player on my team.

But what I do want, is a 4th line guy who can skate and hit everything that moves with a big hit.

So Boucher might be able to be that if he can stay healthy.

So basically, I don't see either as top 9 players, but I see Boucher as the better stylistic player for the 4th line, so I take Boucher. Again, not because he's the better player...because he's not.

 

[TheNewEra]

I think Reichel is the better player, but I say no.

I don't see either being an impact player on my team.

But what I do want, is a 4th line guy who can skate and hit everything that moves with a big hit.

So Boucher might be able to be that if he can stay healthy.

So basically, I don't see either as top 9 players, but I see Boucher as the better stylistic player for the 4th line, so I take Boucher. Again, not because he's the better player...because he's not.

This is a good summary of why I say no too

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

I'd rather Boucher as he could become a 4th line physical, pest type player.

Reichel can play, but it needs to be on bad teams to get those better minutes.

Reichel isn't playing top 6 in Ottawa, or possibly next year, either They'll have free agents, or developed players that will likely pass him between now and then, too.

I'd say Ottawa passes.

 

[Leafshater67]

Boucher is a bottom 6’er in the AHL. He simply is not good. He has not shown any flashes of being an NHL calibre player. I guess the deal makes sense if the hawks want to dump a player for nothing but other than that, nope.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

Same nationality guarantees good connection? Reichel is trash, doesn't hold any value, probably back to Eisbaren Berlin real soon or Swizz league if he's being adventurous. Soft as a butter.

This post is sure to age well lol.

 

[NyQuil]

I'd rather Boucher as he could become a 4th line physical, pest type player.

Reichel can play, but it needs to be on bad teams to get those better minutes.

Reichel isn't playing top 6 in Ottawa, or possibly next year, either They'll have free agents, or developed players that will likely pass him between now and then, too.

I'd say Ottawa passes.

This is where I'm at.

Boucher could recoup some value as a bottom six guy a la Curtis Lazar.

Reichel is better off on Chicago and Boucher is better off on Ottawa, so it's a bit of a strange proposal.

On the other hand, Ottawa doesn't have a lot of skill in the forward prospect pool. I think Reichel still holds more value at this stage.

 

[SpezDispenser]

Boucher is a bottom 6’er in the AHL. He simply is not good. He has not shown any flashes of being an NHL calibre player. I guess the deal makes sense if the hawks want to dump a player for nothing but other than that, nope.

No one knows what he is because he's been constantly injured. Ottawa would pass so they can assess him this year in the AHL and hope to have a 4th line guy who can hit.

 

[NyQuil]

No one knows what he is because he's been constantly injured. Ottawa would pass so they can assess him this year in the AHL and hope to have a 4th line guy who can hit.

During pre-season and camp, there were flashes of Boucher's ability to forecheck hard with speed and generate turnovers through hits on the end boards leading to the cycle.

But they aren't consistent enough for a guy who should be desperate to prove his value.

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

During pre-season and camp, there were flashes of Boucher's ability to forecheck hard with speed and generate turnovers through hits on the end boards leading to the cycle.

But they aren't consistent enough for a guy who should be desperate to prove his value.

I think Boucher’s desperation is to stay healthy and just olay hockey right now.

 

[NyQuil]

I think Boucher’s desperation is to stay healthy and just olay hockey right now.

If that's his mentality, he's not going to impress anyone. He doesn't have the skillset to be useful unless he's playing on the edge.

 

[The Devilish Buffoon]

If that's his mentality, he's not going to impress anyone. He doesn't have the skillset to be useful unless he's playing on the edge.

I agree, you are entirety right, but I think realistically the team knew he was starting in the A, he knew it, and I know if I was in charge I would be telling him to focus on finding his rhythm and having a productive, impactful year in the A.

As a fan, we want to see immediate results but the most important thing is for him to just get into a rhythm and play games.

 

[NyQuil]

I agree, you are entirety right, but I think realistically the team knew he was starting in the A, he knew it, and I know if I was in charge I would be telling him to focus on finding his rhythm and having a productive, impactful year in the A.

As a fan, we want to see immediate results but the most important thing is for him to just get into a rhythm and play games.

Yeah, he definitely needs to rack up game experience after his injury troubles.

But he can't stay in passive mode forever or his draft pedigree won't save him as guys are drafted and acquired behind him.