GWT: Champions League - League Stage

[Evilo]

Don't they use the semi automated offsides in the champions league? which should mean lines aren't drawn and it's the cgi used?

I don't know tbh. But both times the line used was used after the ball had left the player's foot.

 

[Duchene2MacKinnon]

They do use semiautomated offside

 

[hatterson]

I think the semi automated stuff is still checked by a human in close cases though.

 

[Islesfan22]

Ederson had some big saves but big blunders as well. Gvardiol wast City best player yesterday.

 

[AlanHUK]

I think the semi automated stuff is still checked by a human in close cases though.

I thought that was for the subjective stuff like interfering with play?

I don't know tbh. But both times the line used was used after the ball had left the player's foot.

If you're using what was posted on that twitter account then it's not what UEFA used, someone's edited it themselves, this is what the UEFA VAR checks look like.



Incidentally that account also drew the lines from the PSG player at a slight angle headed right instead of straight down, so even if they used the 'right frame' it still would have been offside if they'd drawn their own line properly.

 

[Power Man]

 

[Evilo]

I thought that was for the subjective stuff like interfering with play?



If you're using what was posted on that twitter account then it's not what UEFA used, someone's edited it themselves, this is what the UEFA VAR checks look like.



Incidentally that account also drew the lines from the PSG player at a slight angle headed right instead of straight down, so even if they used the 'right frame' it still would have been offside if they'd drawn their own line properly.

But the whole point of the guy is to show that the UEFA offside was made too late since the ball had left the passers foot.

 

[AlanHUK]

But the whole point of the guy is to show that the UEFA offside was made too late since the ball had left the passers foot.

Even if UEFA used the wrong frame (they didn't), in the image he used it's still offside if you draw the yellow lines correctly, he's slanted them to the right for the PSG player in the first example, and in the other example in his thread to the left for the city player to make the PSG player seem onside in both instances.

So either way the correct decision was made and that person is either really bad at drawing vertical lines, or deliberately misleading people for engagement

 

[Scandale du Jour]

As long as Carlo does not bench Asencio...

 

[gary69]

Brugge has dominated early on and goal was coming, which Jutgla scored at 15 mins.

 

[Incubajerks]

As soon as CB dropped in intensity, Atalanta arrived.

 

[Evilo]

Even if UEFA used the wrong frame (they didn't), in the image he used it's still offside if you draw the yellow lines correctly, he's slanted them to the right for the PSG player in the first example, and in the other example in his thread to the left for the city player to make the PSG player seem onside in both instances.

So either way the correct decision was made and that person is either really bad at drawing vertical lines, or deliberately misleading people for engagement

They clearly used the wrong frame.
The account we're talking about isn't a PSG fan or anything. It's specialized in offsides, especially in the EPL.
It clearly shows that he's onside when the ball is passed but an inch offside when UEFA called it (4th image) since the ball was already (barely) gone.

 

[John Price]

late brugge penalty kick gives them 2-1 lead over Atalanta first leg

 

[Savi]

Didn't think that was a pen, but I'll take it
Great game from Brugge, deserved the win although Atalanta had a better 2nd half and Samardžić probably had the best chance of the half

 

[gary69]

Wow, Bayern asleep, Celtic took the lead in 30 secs. Probably their best attacking player this season, Kuhn. No, offside for blocking Neuer's line of sight.

Milan with a very attacking line-up, but their top4 isn't that tough or defensively sound, so team might be run over unless Fofana has a strong match. And Paixao scores after 3 mins in rainy and slippery conditions, Maignan lets the ball go through his hands.

 

[KlausJopling]

Maignan asleep and beat at the near post on a pretty tame shot.

 

[gary69]

Quite a shot by Olise to make it 1-0 for Bayern at 45 mins.