Proposal: CBJ-TOR
- Thread starter Americanadian
- Start date
Better than what I expected to see when I opened this. I think the team likes Sillinger too much to trade him and it's probably not the best value but I'd like a Greaves/Woll tandem in the right move. More realistically expecting Merzlikins/Greaves as our goalies next year
You may not but I'd take him
A1LeafNation
Obsession beats talent everytime!!
- Oct 17, 2010
- 27,637
- 18,949
hamzarocks
Registered User
Would you do Woll + Kampf for Sillinger + Merziklins + 2nd
Elvis has 2 years but makes close to 5M i believe and has been bad for a while on CBJ. Leafs hope he can bounce back for us and take shot he can be 1A in case Stolarz has continued injury concerns or walks in a year.
Leafs would dump Kampf who has 2 years at 2.4M and has no spot for the leafs on the 3th line with Laughton here now
No, he's definitely improved his skating a decent amount. Still working on other parts of his game but he's coming around
A1LeafNation
Obsession beats talent everytime!!
- Oct 17, 2010
- 27,637
- 18,949
Elvis is at 5.4mil. I don't know if I'd be keen on adding a pick because I do think Sillinger has decent upside still. Honestly Elvis does too but I'm not naive enough to expect teams to offer value for that.
Kampf could have a decent 4th line role here if they let Kuraly walk
Then why did you ask a stupid question if you didn't want to listen to the answer? He's moving much better than when he got to the NHL
Fatass
Registered User
- Apr 17, 2017
- 24,380
- 19,851
Woll has zero value. Goalies don’t have much value nowadays. Woll being a middling backup has less than none.
hamzarocks
Registered User
True, could be a fit for both teams.
Ideally I wanted the deal to be a bit more cap neutral
Kampf makes 2.4M and Woll 3.667M so ~6.1M
Elvis is at 5.4M and Sillinger at 2.25M so ~7.65M.
Would you guys take the Krok (Calle Jarnkrok) back instead of adding a pick? He makes 2.1M for 1 more season and would bring CBJ cap in too 8.2M (excess of ~600K taken on in the deal)
I think there is a trade to be made between CBJ and TOR. Woll seems like a a solid target for CBJ and is young enough that he can be their starter in a few years when the peak contention begins
Columbus has a decent amount of depth options that I don't think they'd be looking to bring more in. That and I believe the team (multiple management groups and coaching staffs) really like the player/person. They kept trying to force him into an offensive role where honestly he sucked but they smartened up and put him in a checking role where he looked pretty good. I think if Columbus targeted a goalie it would be the route of a pick and/or player they don't see as a longterm option going out
lanceuppercut75
Registered User
Columbus already has Greaves and Merzlikins, with Tarasov (RFA) possibly staying also.
Doesn't make sense for Columbus unless they're trading Merzlikins for a skater or buying him out. Greaves isn't going anywhere.
From a Leafs perspective, if they wanted to trade Woll, they would be smarter IMO to try and trade Woll or Woll plus for a guy like Kochetkov, Ersson, Hofer, Ingram, or even Merzlikins with retention.
Doesn't make sense for Columbus unless they're trading Merzlikins for a skater or buying him out. Greaves isn't going anywhere.
From a Leafs perspective, if they wanted to trade Woll, they would be smarter IMO to try and trade Woll or Woll plus for a guy like Kochetkov, Ersson, Hofer, Ingram, or even Merzlikins with retention.
I am Canadian
AM34|WN88|MM16
Xoggz22
Registered User
Xoggz22
Registered User
SteelCityCannon
Registered User
- Mar 25, 2017
- 598
- 2,756
What do we do with Elvis if we did this?
Plus, the team is really high on Sillinger.
People forget, he's still only 22. Nowhere near his peak. I wouldn't move him for a goalie. Not an outrageous proposal but I don't think Columbus entertains it.
Plus, the team is really high on Sillinger.
People forget, he's still only 22. Nowhere near his peak. I wouldn't move him for a goalie. Not an outrageous proposal but I don't think Columbus entertains it.
squashmaple
gudbranson apologist
I would absollutely do this, but Elvis in Toronto is a horrible idea. He's volatile now in Columbus bwtween the media and fans. Sending him to the league's tinderbox would only end badly.
leafsfan2point0
Registered User
- Jun 8, 2011
- 1,933
- 2,716
It’s a thin goalie market for free agents. No way am I interested in trading a young and solid 1b goalie unless it’s an overpay.
Namikaze Minato
Registered User
A Colombus proposal and we aren't fleecing them for Boone? Poppycock!
