CBJ Board Summer '15 Prospect Rankings: #3

[dru]

Bjorkstrand add Bittner.

 

[SuperGenius]

Bjorkstrand, add Heatherington

 

[stevo61]

The good news for this viewpoint is that Carlsson only has one vote in the current poll and Heatherington leads among the "adds," which should mean you'll get a chance to vote for Dillon over Gabe sooner than later. See how it all works out when we vote?

I didnt just say this poll did I? I mean in general. If theres something Im missing with Carlsson then great, with the way I feel about Heatherington and Carlsson is better then Ill be more then happy

 

[Double-Shift Lasse]

I didnt just say this poll did I? I mean in general. If theres something Im missing with Carlsson then great, with the way I feel about Heatherington and Carlsson is better then Ill be more then happy

OK cool. But where else are you seeing that he's clear-cut above Heatherington? And, absent your indicating anything of the sort, and given that we're in the polling, and you quoted "add Heatherington (like last time)", what else was I supposed to think?

 

[Nanabijou]

Kerby. Add Bittner

 

[stevo61]

OK cool. But where else are you seeing that he's clear-cut above Heatherington? And, absent your indicating anything of the sort, and given that we're in the polling, and you quoted "add Heatherington (like last time)", what else was I supposed to think?

That a question can be sincere and not cynical or insulting to Samkow because its assumed that I dont like the options.
I really can't remember all the places that have ranked Carlsson over Heatherington but Ive seen it in the prospect section and NHL.com rates Collins over Heatherington so Im sure Carlsson will be (I've seen more but cant remember of\f the top of my head so i dont want to go searching). Ive seen Heatherington and Bjorkstrand live more then Ive seen any of our other guys play and love his game so I'm wondering if people here actually know if theres something about Carlsson that seperates him

 

[TaketheCannoli]

Rychel add Bittner

 

[Samkow]

I usually post these at the first result but better late than never.

Simply vote for the prospect you think is the best prospect of the above. This poll will be open 24 hours.

This uses HF Criteria, hence why some players have spent time in the NHL.

2014

Rank | Player | Position #1 |Alexander Wennberg|C
#2 |Kerby Rychel|LW
#3 |Sonny Milano|LW
#4 |Tim Erixon|D
#5 |Oliver Bjorkstrand|RW
#6 |Mike Reilly|D
#7 |Marko Dano|C
#8 |Anton Forsberg|G
#9 |Dillon Heatherington|D
#10 |Oscar Dansk|G
#11 |Simon Hjalmarsson|RW
#12 |Daniel Zaar|RW
#13 |Michael Chaput|C
#14 |Ryan Collins|D
#15 |Josh Anderson|RW
#16 |Jerry D'Amigo|RW
#17 |Markus Soberg|RW
#18 |Thomas Tynan|C
#19 |Elvins Merzlikins|G
#20 |Blake Siebenaler|D

2013

Rank | Player | Position #1 |Ryan Murray|D
#2 |Cam Atkinson|RW
#3 |Alexander Wennberg|C
#4 |Boone Jenner|C
#5 |Tim Erixon|D
#6 |Kerby Rychel|LW
#7 |Dalton Prout|D
#8 |Marko Dano|C
#9 |Oscar Dansk|G
#10 |Cody Goloubef|D
#11 |Anton Forsberg|G
#12 |Dillon Heatherington|D
#13 |David Savard|D
#14 |Oliver Bjorkstrand|RW
#15 |Mike Reilly|D
#16 |Michael Chaput|C
#17 |Jonathan Audy-Marchessault|C
#18 |Daniel Zaar|RW
#19 |Joonas Korpisalo|G
#20 |Nick Moutrey|C

2012

Rank | Player | Position #1 |Ryan Murray|D
#2 |Cam Atkinson|RW
#3 |Tim Erixon|D
#4 |David Savard|D
#5 |Boone Jenner|C
#6 |Oscar Dansk|G
#7 |Matt Calvert|LW
#8 |Michael Chaput|C
#9 |Tomas Kubalik|RW
#10(T) |Anton Forsberg|G
#10(T) |Cody Goloubef|D
#12 |Jonathan Audy-Marchessault|LW
#13 |Thomas Tynan|C
#14 |Mike Reilly|D
#15 |Allen York|G
#16 |Will Weber|D
#17 |Joonas Korpisalo|G
#18 |Dalton Prout|D
#19 |Daniel Zaar|RW
#20 |Lukas Sedlak|C

2011

Rank | Player | Position #1 |Ryan Johansen|C
#2 |Matt Calvert|LW
#3 |David Savard|D
#4 |John Moore|D
#5 |Tomas Kubalik|RW
#6 |Cam Atkinson|RW
#7 |Maksim Mayorov|LW
#8 |Boone Jenner|C
#9 |Cody Goloubef|D
#10 |Allen York|G
#11 |Petr Straka|RW
#12 |Michael Chaput|C
#13 |Will Weber|D
#14 |Theo Ruth|D
#15 |Thomas Tynan|C
#16 |Anton Blomqvist|D
#17 |Oliver Gabriel|LW
#18 |Seth Ambroz|LW
#19 |Dalton Smith|LW
#20 |Thomas Larkin|D

2010

2009

 

[Tulipunaruusu*]

Edit: just kidding, he only played 7 games in the SHL. Maybe he has a higher hockey IQ?! They're both pretty similar as far as play style I just think Carlsson might be a little further ahead in his development.

Carlsson played also 10 games in the play-offs while Linköping dropped in the semi-finals.

 

[CBJx614]

I usually post these at the first result but better late than never.

Simply vote for the prospect you think is the best prospect of the above. This poll will be open 24 hours.

This uses HF Criteria, hence why some players have spent time in the NHL.

2014

Rank | Player | Position #1 |Alexander Wennberg|C
#2 |Kerby Rychel|LW
#3 |Sonny Milano|LW
#4 |Tim Erixon|D
#5 |Oliver Bjorkstrand|RW
#6 |Mike Reilly|D
#7 |Marko Dano|C
#8 |Anton Forsberg|G
#9 |Dillon Heatherington|D
#10 |Oscar Dansk|G
#11 |Simon Hjalmarsson|RW
#12 |Daniel Zaar|RW
#13 |Michael Chaput|C
#14 |Ryan Collins|D
#15 |Josh Anderson|RW
#16 |Jerry D'Amigo|RW
#17 |Markus Soberg|RW
#18 |Thomas Tynan|C
#19 |Elvins Merzlikins|G
#20 |Blake Siebenaler|D

2013

Rank | Player | Position #1 |Ryan Murray|D
#2 |Cam Atkinson|RW
#3 |Alexander Wennberg|C
#4 |Boone Jenner|C
#5 |Tim Erixon|D
#6 |Kerby Rychel|LW
#7 |Dalton Prout|D
#8 |Marko Dano|C
#9 |Oscar Dansk|G
#10 |Cody Goloubef|D
#11 |Anton Forsberg|G
#12 |Dillon Heatherington|D
#13 |David Savard|D
#14 |Oliver Bjorkstrand|RW
#15 |Mike Reilly|D
#16 |Michael Chaput|C
#17 |Jonathan Audy-Marchessault|C
#18 |Daniel Zaar|RW
#19 |Joonas Korpisalo|G
#20 |Nick Moutrey|C

2012

Rank | Player | Position #1 |Ryan Murray|D
#2 |Cam Atkinson|RW
#3 |Tim Erixon|D
#4 |David Savard|D
#5 |Boone Jenner|C
#6 |Oscar Dansk|G
#7 |Matt Calvert|LW
#8 |Michael Chaput|C
#9 |Tomas Kubalik|RW
#10(T) |Anton Forsberg|G
#10(T) |Cody Goloubef|D
#12 |Jonathan Audy-Marchessault|LW
#13 |Thomas Tynan|C
#14 |Mike Reilly|D
#15 |Allen York|G
#16 |Will Weber|D
#17 |Joonas Korpisalo|G
#18 |Dalton Prout|D
#19 |Daniel Zaar|RW #18 |Lukas Sedlak|C

2011

Rank | Player | Position #1 |Ryan Johansen|C
#2 |Matt Calvert|LW
#3 |David Savard|D
#4 |John Moore|D
#5 |Tomas Kubalik|RW
#6 |Cam Atkinson|RW
#7 |Maksim Mayorov|LW
#8 |Boone Jenner|C
#9 |Cody Goloubef|D
#10 |Allen York|G
#11 |Petr Straka|RW
#12 |Michael Chaput|C
#13 |Will Weber|D
#14 |Theo Ruth|D
#15 |Thomas Tynan|C
#16 |Anton Blomqvist|D
#17 |Oliver Gabriel|LW
#18 |Seth Ambroz|LW
#19 |Dalton Smith|LW
#20 |Thomas Larkin|D

2010

2009

It really is crazy how much these change from year to year. Only 6 of the top 10 are still with the club, Wennberg graduated and Dansk will likely fall out of the top 10. Basically half of the top 10 will be completely different after this year. With Rychel getting passed by Werenski, Milano, and Bjorkstrand.

My guess to round out the top 10

5) Forsberg
6)Paliotta
7)Heatherington
8)Collins
9)Bittner
10)Carlsson

 

[Double-Shift Lasse]

That a question can be sincere and not cynical or insulting to Samkow because its assumed that I dont like the options.
I really can't remember all the places that have ranked Carlsson over Heatherington but Ive seen it in the prospect section and NHL.com rates Collins over Heatherington so Im sure Carlsson will be (I've seen more but cant remember of\f the top of my head so i dont want to go searching). Ive seen Heatherington and Bjorkstrand live more then Ive seen any of our other guys play and love his game so I'm wondering if people here actually know if theres something about Carlsson that seperates him

Oh my I'm sorry, that's not the point I was making. Only that often times more information and context is helpful in posting and improves the quality of the dialogue is all.

All this after my first post which simply extolled the virtues of a democratic process.

 

[EspenK]

All this after my first post which simply extolled the virtues of a democratic process.

One only has to look to Washington D.C. to see how true this is.

 

[DarkandStormy]

It's funny to see Savard go from 5 to 3 to 4 to 13 to starter to top 4 D to best RH D on the team.