Proposal: Cayden Primeau to Edmonton

[Bouboumaster]

Montréal has good ol' Monty as our starter, and Dobes feel like he's ready too.
And we have Fowler coming up in a couple of years

Primeau was solid last year but he feels like the odd man this time around

Primeau for a 2nd? Interested?

Click to read more...

 

[Mr Kot]

I give skinner, enjoy

 

[Team_Spirit]

No

 

[Bouboumaster]

I give skinner, enjoy

No man, we traded our own Skinner last year (Allen), we don't need more of them, we need less of them

 

[ElPrimeTime]

From an Oilers POV, I would decline. Based on their AHL stats, I can't see that much of a difference between Primeau and Rodrigue. I'd give him a shot before utilizing a 2nd on a goalie who isn't a clear upgrade.

 

[beowulf]

Montenbault is not the future in nets and Dobes in not NHL ready after only one ok season in the AHL. Primeau will be around for at least this season in Montreal, maybe longer.

 

[BLNY]

Montréal has good ol' Monty as our starter, and Dobes feel like he's ready too.
And we have Fowler coming up in a couple of years

Primeau was solid last year but he feels like the odd man this time around

Primeau for a 2nd? Interested?

no

 

[Treb]

Primeau is not proven enough for that kind of value.

My prediction is that he'll get traded this summer for some mid/late pick and/or prospects if Dobes push hard enough and we sign Fowler and Miller.

 

[Frederixx]

They need a true #1 proven goalie. No sense in trading for another maybe.

Give whatever it takes and grab a true gem

 

[The Gr8 Dane]

Just keep prims as the backup

 

[CanadienShark]

Primeau doesn't have that kind of value and I don't think the Habs are ready to move him either. Pass from both sides.

 

[Walrus26]

I give skinner, enjoy

Wish there was a GG well played emoji.

 

[Figgy44]

Wish there was a GG well played emoji.

Would a gif of Glen Gulutzan throwing a stick into the stands be appropriate?

 

[Bouboumaster]

They need a true #1 proven goalie. No sense in trading for another maybe.

Give whatever it takes and grab a true gem

Nobody ever trade a #1 proven goalie

It doesn't happen, unless in extremely rare occasions aka the Bob Trade

Edmonton best option is to find a young goalie prospect that is a diamond in the rough

Primeau doesn't have that kind of value and I don't think the Habs are ready to move him either. Pass from both sides.

I think we are, and I think the Oilers need a solid Plan B asap

no

yes

Primeau is not proven enough for that kind of value.

My prediction is that he'll get traded this summer for some mid/late pick and/or prospects if Dobes push hard enough and we sign Fowler and Miller.

I don't think he ends up the year in Montréal, as he's, IMO, the odd man here

 

[Bouboumaster]

Montenbault is not the future in nets and Dobes in not NHL ready after only one ok season in the AHL. Primeau will be around for at least this season in Montreal, maybe longer.

Monty ain't the future, but he's the present (and the next 2 or 3 years) and I feel like Dobes is actually ready
I was mightily impressed by him this off season

 

[Bourne Endeavor]

I don't know if Edmonton would even claim Primeau off waivers, let alone pay a 2nd for him. And that isn't a slight on Primeau but rather the low value goalies generally have and him not really being an improvement on what they have.

 

[DaveG]

Would a gif of Glen Gulutzan throwing a stick into the stands be appropriate?

well, now I need to see this

 

[Figgy44]

well, now I need to see this

EDIT: and here's the original video.

 

[Eegs]

No one to backfill for Dobes really in Laval, and he could use another full season in the AHL anyhow.

 

[beowulf]

Monty ain't the future, but he's the present (and the next 2 or 3 years) and I feel like Dobes is actually ready
I was mightily impressed by him this off season

I guess I rather Dobes get some more AHL time as he had average at best start last year but ended the season on a real strong streak. He is only 23 I believe so one more year and being the first call up won't hurt him.

 

[Bouboumaster]

I guess I rather Dobes get some more AHL time as she had average at best start last year but ended the season on a real strong streak. He is only 23 I believe so one more year and being the first call up won't hurt him.

I guess it's valid too

Like, I'm ok keeping it, but I'm a huge fan of getting assets like picks

Edmonton as a need, Montréal as the merchandise so for me it's a natural fit

I don't know if Edmonton would even claim Primeau off waivers, let alone pay a 2nd for him. And that isn't a slight on Primeau but rather the low value goalies generally have and him not really being an improvement on what they have.

I think they do, I think that the second Primeau hit the waivers, a bunch of team are putting calls, and Edmonton is one of them

 

[Baksfamous112]

Edmonton window is open now. No reason to trade for a guy who’s just entered the league and still getting his reps in. Too unreliable

 

[Weltschmerz]

Nobody ever trade a #1 proven goalie

It doesn't happen, unless in extremely rare occasions aka the Bob Trade

Edmonton best option is to find a young goalie prospect that is a diamond in the rough



I think we are, and I think the Oilers need a solid Plan B asap



yes



I don't think he ends up the year in Montréal, as he's, IMO, the odd man here

Ullmark was just traded this offseason.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Ullmark was just traded this offseason.

And we'll see if it paid off

 

[spaghtti]

Ullmark was just traded this offseason.

I was going to comment the same thing , you beat me to it

And we'll see if it paid off

He won the vezna the year before last