Carson Soucy to have a hearing for Cross-check to Connor McDavid - suspended 1 game (MOD WARNING IN OP)

[Leonardo87]

MOD NOTE:

If you can't post in here without constantly trying to troll each other, you won't be posting in here. Consider this the one and only warning you'll get.

Click to read more...

 

[WetcoastOrca]

Campbell didn't suck worse than Skinner with Woodcroft coaching. Both were equally bad. Campbell was waived to change things up and was never tried with new coach and new defensive strategy.

Skinner could've been pulled after the 3rd goal if not after period 1. Even I'm 3rd Oilers had plenty of time for a comeback. It was a good game with Oilers fighting til the end. The issue here is the assault after the final buzzer .. I don't think many saw what happened to McDavid otherwise the bench could have cleared if McD stayed down on the ice and replays of that play shown.

Campbell is mediocre in the AHL and has been terrible in the playoffs. He was waived because he’s not an NHL goalie. He’s no more the answer than Skinner or Pickard.

 

[CantHaveTkachev]

I wouldn't use "man of steel" to describe McDavid, either. Especially hilarious considering the topic of this thread.

Why? is he injured?

 

[MontrealCanuck]

Lumberjack? Oh come on, take the homer glasses off. He hardly even hit him, there were worse slashes and cross checks during the game that the refs don't care about at all.

Vancouver fans of all fanbases accusing others of whining and diving is absolutely ridiculous. Your team has been among the worst for diving for 25 years.

You should probably update your avatar to have him on the Olympic diving, makes more sense than putting his face on Superman. The fan of team whine and dive is accusing others of having homer glasses when he thinks a slight shove that happens a thousand times every game is justification for a lumberjack swing of the stick.

 

[Sasha Orlov]

Its not advocating when he’s near tears because he’s not getting another PP. Every single time he’s touched he has something to complain about.

I cry in court all the time, it actually works pretty well

 

[ManofSteel55]

One heck of a “swat” here


Who’s going to retaliate? Janmark? Nuge?

Nice screen shot. This is why video matters though. He was off balance from the shove he got right before - this was just as much him trying to regain balance as anything. Then he gave him a tap on the pants.

 

[Kamus]

The quite simple thing would have been if McDavid kept his stick to himself. He initiated the whole thing with that 2 hander. He decided to write a cheque his ass couldn’t cash.

Again, watch the video Saucy initiated by cross checking McDavid before McDavid responds with a slash. How did he initiate? If you said he shouldn’t have responded that would be more accurate.

 

[innitfam]

Soucy should be suspended the rest of the series for his own safety.

Lmao who on Edmonton would take out Soucy. Guy is huge.

 

[NyQuil]

I see these being very similar.

They are both retaliatory acts.

Sorry, the issue a lot of (sens) fans had with the play was it was after the whistle (5 seconds left in the decided game). No real deference here. Both games were over.

Sorry, but the league was adamant both in its initial judgment and in its response to Toronto’s appeal that scoring a goal is not an instigating act and therefore Rielly was not retaliating but rather instigating against a defenceless opponent.

Not similar.

 

[Kamus]

Get a grip on reality.

Soucy lightly pushes McDavid away. This happens 100x per game and in every single scrum.

McDavid responds with a baseball chop to the legs. He escalates it. McBabys*** is just so pathetic he can't handle what's coming after he starts some s***

So you agree saucy initiated. Thank you for proving my point.

 

[TheBeard]

One heck of a “swat” here


Who’s going to retaliate? Janmark? Nuge?

You don’t think Edmonton has guys who’ll go the extra mile? Ekholm? Perry? Kane?

They honestly should have kept Kostin.

 

[Artemi Panarin]

Soucy should be suspended the rest of the series for his own safety.

"Oh no, Corey Perry and Evander Kane have it out for me!"

 

[ChaoticOrange]

Soucy should be suspended the rest of the series for his own safety.

our so-called toughness has been a no-show in this series so far except for Nurse on Pettersson, I think Soucy will be fine.

I will say that targeting a superstar like Vancouver did that is a good way to wake the Oilers up. They were the better team by far in the last two periods, but they need to start games like that, not just finish them.

 

[CupofOil]

A two handed slash after the game is a lot. McDavid initiated it and should accept the consequences.

I guess you missed it when Soucy initiated it with a push after the whistle? I'm guessing you did or are wearing Canuck blinders.

 

[TheBeard]

our so-called toughness has been a no-show in this series so far except for Nurse on Pettersson, I think Soucy will be fine.

I will say that targeting a superstar like Vancouver did that is a good way to wake the Oilers up. They were the better team by far in the last two periods, but they need to start games like that, not just finish them.

If any game gets out of hand I wouldn’t count out any of the players to try and get their licks in. Doesn’t take much for things to go too far.

 

[ManofSteel55]

You should probably update your avatar to have him on the Olympic diving, makes more sense than putting his face on Superman. The fan of team whine and dive is accusing others of having homer glasses when he thinks a slight shove that happens a thousand times every game is justification for a lumberjack swing of the stick.

The Canucks are the worst diving team in the league and have been for 25 years.

I hope you never try to chop wood if you think a lumberjack swings that soft.

 

[flying squirrel]

Kucherov's neck shot ??? -vs- McDavid neck shot ???

Another example of how players are treated differently within sports across-the-board. Both Kucherov & McDavid's plays should be treated same, but consistency is not a top priority for sport$.

 

[LivingRentFree]

Again, watch the video Saucy initiated by cross checking McDavid before McDavid responds with a slash. How did he initiate? If you said he shouldn’t have responded that would be more accurate.

Cross check and push are two very different things

 

[TheBeard]

Lmao who on Edmonton would take out Soucy. Guy is huge.

So is Steve Moore.

 

[MikeK]

Should be a fine at most.

 

[nabob]

our so-called toughness has been a no-show in this series so far except for Nurse on Pettersson, I think Soucy will be fine.

I will say that targeting a superstar like Vancouver did that is a good way to wake the Oilers up. They were the better team by far in the last two periods, but they need to start games like that, not just finish them.

Yep, a knee on knee hit to Hughes should suffice. Maybe have someone push Highes first so that the guy who throws the knee isn’t at fault.

 

[WetcoastOrca]

our so-called toughness has been a no-show in this series so far except for Nurse on Pettersson, I think Soucy will be fine.

I will say that targeting a superstar like Vancouver did that is a good way to wake the Oilers up. They were the better team by far in the last two periods, but they need to start games like that, not just finish them.

Could work either way imo. Could wake up the non contributing Oiler players or could embolden the Canucks with an us against the league mentality.
Personally I’m hoping the Oilers try to get revenge like the Leafs did against Marchand.

 

[LivingRentFree]

You don’t think Edmonton has guys who’ll go the extra mile? Ekholm? Perry? Kane?

They honestly should have kept Kostin.

Nobody is afraid of Kane and Perry in 2024. Ekholm has like what, 3 career fights?

 

[Dust]

Zadorov should offer to serve or cover any discipline, it's entirely his fault this ended up being anything.

 

[M88K]

The Canucks are the worst diving team in the league and have been for 25 years.

I hope you never try to chop wood if you think a lumberjack swings that soft.

Watch a wild game

 

[ManofSteel55]

Cross check and push are two very different things

They really aren't a lot of the time. It's the same motion. A lot of the time, the only difference is if a guy touches with the stick or his gloves first.