tarheelhockey
Offside Review Specialist
I disagree completely. Not a player like Rantanen in 2025. If this was 1955 when player salaries were not disclosed and players were being railroaded... sure... but not today. Anyone can go online in 5 seconds and see what any player in the NHL is making. Rantanen is in an elite tier -- there are clear comps for a player like him.
However, the same issue would present itself... it's no longer what a player is "worth" in isolation... it's more about being able to pay him reasonable worth while keeping a contending team together in a cap world. Today, there's nowhere to hide -- player salaries, cap hits, and team payrolls are fully disclosed. Rantanen can figure out in 5 minutes what he "should be paid" as well as "what the Avs can reasonably pay" and he can sit down with the GM over a beer a work a deal... IF he wants to stay in Colorado.
Do you truly think a GM would try to tell Rantanen to his face that he's only worth 8.5 a year? Lmao... heck, you or I could represent Rantanen in our sleep. The issue is that players need to be direct with their agents and state their intent. Rantanen should have told his agent, "I know I'm likely worth 13.5 on the open market, but Nate took a bit less a couple of times... and Cale is up and will need a raise too... so tell the Avs I'm offering a hometown discount of 11.5 to stay. I want this deal put to bed by Jan. 1st... and I need to be kept in the loop daily."
Instead, Rantanen likely trusted his agent whose bluff was called. Lesson learned. If you want to stay in Colorado, either grow a set and demand your agent gets it done... or call the GM directly and work it out... or try to convince the NHL to remove the hard cap so you can have your cake and eat it too. Or, ultimately get traded, lol.
Do you seriously think that is what negotiating an NHL contract consists of? Deciding what you should be paid, then looking at the team’s cap space, and shooting down the middle?
So you think an NHL player, armed with two publicly available numbers, is qualified to sit down with a beer across the table from a team of professional contract negotiators and hammer out a multimillion dollar contract structure, bonuses, incentives, trade clauses? That he’s capable of winning in arbitration? That he understands all of his rights and restrictions enumerated in the 50 articles of the CBA? That he’s prepared to negotiate endorsements and media with corporate lawyers? That he knows how to file a grievance with the union? That he’s able to negotiate contracts in Sweden or Finland? That he can speak to the media solo and without any coaching, during a high stakes negotiation, without saying something he’ll soon regret? That he understands the financial and tax implications of all of these agreements?
That he has time to do all of that while also being a professional athlete?
That he even has the educational and professional attainment necessary to attempt any of this with a reasonable level of confidence?
Agents don’t become multimillionaires by accident. Thinking active NHL players could do this job is like thinking you can just show up in court and represent yourself on felony charges, no problemo man.