I mean you’re right about sustainability being important, but Miller also has a 99 point year
Yes, it's right there, but still isn't.
It's like back in the day when Kessel was traded to the Leafs. Both sides seemed happy and both sides called him a 40 goal scorer because he was on pace for it and only need 1, or 3 goals and missed 10 games.
The main difference here is he didn't score 40 and never did in his career.
It might be just a slight chance, but McDavid is a 100 point player, because you know he's going to hit 100+ points a season if he's healthy. Maybe even if he isn't fully healthy.
In the previous three years, he has had a 103 and a 99 point season. Are we really going to get that pedantic?
Yes, mainly because he didn't actually hit it.
If someone scores 50 goals, they are, by definition, a 50 goal scorer. It just requires context to tell the full story. You just made one of the dumbest f***ing posts I’ve ever seen.
Unless you’re trying to gaslight the entire hockey community into thinking it’s the way you’ve described?
A 50 goal scorer is Ovechkin.
Is Chris Kreider a 50 goal scorer ? f*** no. Is he a player who scored 50 goals once in his career ? Yes, pretty simple.
If I saw Marner is a 90 point player while Miller is a 100 point player, you'd make the assumption that Miller is better when he isn't.
If last week I said name a team that has 2 100 point centres. You're naming Edmonton, but Vancouver would be acceptable in that instance because both Miller and Pettersson have reached the 100 point mark.
Based on your logic and the person who first didn't get it, it's like anyone saying Toronto got a sick deal on a 30 goal scorer by signing Pacioretty for league minimum.
You'd laugh and say despite having a few 30+ goal season under his belt he is no longer a 30 goal scorer.
You also know players have career years and sometimes they reach a new plateau and never reach it again.
Calling Miller, or Pettersson a 100 point centre is disingenuous.
I can't make it anymore simpler for you. If you don't get it.
Actually, I can. How can a player be labeled something if he averages less than that average ?
He can't
Phone drop.
Now the screen is cracked, but worth it