An elite playmaker (nope!). A big accurate shot from the point that demands respect (nope!). A lethal one-timer (nope!).
Semin is all three of those.
What does Semin do in our PP breakout? Stands stationary at the far blue while a defenseman slowly S-curves his way up the ice. We don't just allow teams to stand us up at the blue line, we
encourage it. And when they do stand up, our only option is to dump the puck in and pursue it with the guys who have been standing completely still at the blue line.
When we manage to get across the blue line with possession (maybe 25% of the time) what's our go-to play for Semin? The cross-slot pass that every video coach in the league has scouted at this point?
What's our go-to play for Skinner? Having him walk out of the corner at a sharp angle and try wristers off the goalie's toes until one deflects in?
What's our go-to play for Eric? Can we even say we
have one for a guy who's only scored once? As much flak as I've given him this season, the PP is the difference between his current production and a point-per-game pace. Why is he such a prolific scorer against 5 opponents but can't buy a decent shot against 4?
Sekera has shown unbelievable playmaking skill this year. Liles is a pure puck mover. Murphy is a phenom when he has time and space.
It doesn't add up that this group should be putrid with the man advantage. Whatever Muller envisions on the PP (and it remains unclear exactly what that is), it wastes the skills that this roster offers. In no way am I convinced that this team doesn't have the talent to break 13% on the PP.