CAN A KARLSSON TRADE EVEN GET BACK WHAT WE PAID FOR DUCHENE?
ACTUAL PRICE WE PAID FOR DUCHENE
1) Kyle Turris
2) Andrew Hammond
3) 1st - 2019 (3rd overall) = current draft position (good 2019 estimate if we move Karlsson, Hoffman, Brassard, etc)
4) 1st - 2017 (28th overall) = Shane Bowers
5) 3rd - 2018 (65th overall) = current draft position
- If Melnyk wanted Turris gone, Dorion could have traded directly with Nashville for the same return.
- Considering we're now in re-build mode 3 months later, it would have been nice to see this happen.
DE FACTO PRICE WE PAID FOR DUCHENE
1) 1st - 2019 (3rd overall) = current draft position (good 2019 estimate if we move Karlsson, Hoffman, Brassard, etc)
2) 1st - 2017 (28th overall) = Shane Bowers
3) 2nd - 2014 (42nd overall) = Vlad Kamenev (Turris trade)
4) 2nd - 2016 (47th overall) = Samuel Girard (Turris trade)
5) 2nd - 2018 (59th overall) = current draft position (Turris trade)
6) 3rd - 2018 (65th overall) = current draft position
7) Andrew Hammond
RUMORED PACKAGES FOR KARLSSON (ONLINE ARTICLES)
1) Edmonton = 1st (2018) + 2nd (2018) + Oscar Klefbom
2) Dallas = 1st (2018) + Radek Faksa + Jake Oettinger
3) Philadelphia = 1st (2018) + Travis Konecny + Robert Hagg
- These packages don't seem nearly as good as what we gave up for Duchene.
- I've also read that Melnyk might force someone to take Bobby Ryan's contract if they want Karlsson.
- If that happens, the price will come way down.
- If Melnyk wasn't so cheap, he could retain half of Ryan's cap hit & get rid of him with zero effort.
- Ryan actually has similar stats to Duchene over the past few years.
- Using Dorion's logic, Bobby Ryan (at $3.7m x 4 years) should bring back a Duchene sized package.
- That's bad logic....and Melnyk's too cheap.
Anyways.
What do you think?....Can Karlsson return the full cost of Duchene?....Or more/less?
ACTUAL PRICE WE PAID FOR DUCHENE
1) Kyle Turris
2) Andrew Hammond
3) 1st - 2019 (3rd overall) = current draft position (good 2019 estimate if we move Karlsson, Hoffman, Brassard, etc)
4) 1st - 2017 (28th overall) = Shane Bowers
5) 3rd - 2018 (65th overall) = current draft position
- If Melnyk wanted Turris gone, Dorion could have traded directly with Nashville for the same return.
- Considering we're now in re-build mode 3 months later, it would have been nice to see this happen.
DE FACTO PRICE WE PAID FOR DUCHENE
1) 1st - 2019 (3rd overall) = current draft position (good 2019 estimate if we move Karlsson, Hoffman, Brassard, etc)
2) 1st - 2017 (28th overall) = Shane Bowers
3) 2nd - 2014 (42nd overall) = Vlad Kamenev (Turris trade)
4) 2nd - 2016 (47th overall) = Samuel Girard (Turris trade)
5) 2nd - 2018 (59th overall) = current draft position (Turris trade)
6) 3rd - 2018 (65th overall) = current draft position
7) Andrew Hammond
RUMORED PACKAGES FOR KARLSSON (ONLINE ARTICLES)
1) Edmonton = 1st (2018) + 2nd (2018) + Oscar Klefbom
2) Dallas = 1st (2018) + Radek Faksa + Jake Oettinger
3) Philadelphia = 1st (2018) + Travis Konecny + Robert Hagg
- These packages don't seem nearly as good as what we gave up for Duchene.
- I've also read that Melnyk might force someone to take Bobby Ryan's contract if they want Karlsson.
- If that happens, the price will come way down.
- If Melnyk wasn't so cheap, he could retain half of Ryan's cap hit & get rid of him with zero effort.
- Ryan actually has similar stats to Duchene over the past few years.
- Using Dorion's logic, Bobby Ryan (at $3.7m x 4 years) should bring back a Duchene sized package.
- That's bad logic....and Melnyk's too cheap.
Anyways.
What do you think?....Can Karlsson return the full cost of Duchene?....Or more/less?
Last edited: