Pavel Buchnevich
"Pavel Buchnevich The Fake"
I get what you are saying but I also think of those two players kind of like opposites.
I think Perreault has much better tools than Zary (faster, better shot) but doesn't seem to use them much. He doesn't have the diligence or consistency that Zary has. Perreault is a little bit polarizing, I think. His talent is often said to be top ten but he'll go anywhere from 13th to 33rd.
I mostly agree. I wasn't stating they play the exact same way. I was comparing the discussion surrounding them, as I consider both to be very underrated players.
I think of them both in the 2c/3c category. Holloway has a lot more questions about his scoring smarts, but he's going to be a beast in the NHL. I'd say safer than Zary who doesn't have the elite skating. Looking at the Rangers lineup, Holloway would provide the power up the middle, which is the biggest thing they're missing up front. I don't think they're in as desperate need of a boom/bust pick as some teams are, not with Zibby and Panarin there.
I think Zary is at least a line better. I think Zary's projection is a 2C, and Holloway is a 3C. The Rangers don't really need someone like Holloway. We have a version like him with Brett Howden. We have Chytil, who has great size, speed, power. We even drafted a young center who was known for areas other than pure scoring, Lias Andersson, in the top 10.
If the Rangers pick Holloway anywhere earlier than the 20's, I am not going to like the pick.