Seravalli: - Buffalo may not have a choice but to trade Peterka | Page 36 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Seravalli: Buffalo may not have a choice but to trade Peterka

Honestly very little leaks out of Buffalo, if there's any type of rumor that Tampa is after Peterka I'd bet money on Peterka's agent or another GM leaking that before Adams.
Tampa is by and large the same way, most of their moves come out of left field. For instance, nobody brought up Bjorkstrand and Tampa, there wasn’t even a hint that Sergachev was going anywhere, then the McDonagh trade was also totally random.

Thing is, I’ve heard a lot about TB-Buf lately, with Tuch at the deadline and Peterka now. Wonder where it’s coming from
 
Peterka's agent then. The Lightning don't even remark on obvious situations. And if they do its like "lol yeah, we're totally signing our RFA's"
It could just be that TB has called on two guys that are open to moving or want to light a fire under Adams to get the Sabres back in the mix in Tuch and Peterka. Their agents leaking this would make a lot of sense. Nightmare scenario for Buf would be if Peterka said “I’m only playing in TB” but doubt that’s the case. Although if Peterka really wants out I’m not sure how much leverage he actually needs. But think a prerequisite would either be trading Cirelli (which might end up hurting the F group by leaving a void that upgrading at W wouldn’t fill) or trading Cernak (which, in the unlikely event that he waived his NMC, really leaves the defense in a bad spot). Definitely an interesting situation and kind of fits the TB mold of trading away assets for young “sure things” so they basically never have to draft.
 
From what have heard from the actual player, I’m pretty sure what Peterka wants more than anything is a big long-term contract.

He’s a kid from Munich, so I can see him preferring another vibe to Buffalo in terms of cities.

But he has shown no outward signs of being unhappy with the team itself or his role on it, or of his priority being “I want out”.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SECRET SQUIRREL
It could just be that TB has called on two guys that are open to moving or want to light a fire under Adams to get the Sabres back in the mix in Tuch and Peterka. Their agents leaking this would make a lot of sense. Nightmare scenario for Buf would be if Peterka said “I’m only playing in TB” but doubt that’s the case. Although if Peterka really wants out I’m not sure how much leverage he actually needs. But think a prerequisite would either be trading Cirelli (which might end up hurting the F group by leaving a void that upgrading at W wouldn’t fill) or trading Cernak (which, in the unlikely event that he waived his NMC, really leaves the defense in a bad spot). Definitely an interesting situation and kind of fits the TB mold of trading away assets for young “sure things” so they basically never have to draft.
The Lightning will be okay if they move Cirelli because his playoff deployment consists solely of "Shut down the other team!!" while our collective playoff offense never gets out of 2nd gear. Don't let the numbers fool you. Our coaching staff simply realized 4 years ago (when we tried for that 3rd straight title) that we can just run dead puck hockey 90% of a game and still lead the league in scoring or come close to it. As long as whatever "super line" we construct that's prone to 4 week slumps pops off for random 4 goal nights 15-20 times a year, we're happy. This year it was Guentzel-Point-Kucherov. So come playoff time, shut down whatever this year's "super line" is and Tampa's season is over in a week because we have 2 lines that do jack shit and the Cirelli line mindlessly swarming the neutral zone all night. If we're lucky, they might take 1 of those 8 SOG's we have in a period.

I'd rest easy on JJ Peterka. I doubt he has watched this and said "Thats the only place I wanna go!"
 
This morning on NHL Radio Scott Laughlin (morning show host) said he heard on a "reputable podcast" that Peterka for Necas is a real possibility. Anyone hear the podcast he's referring to?

To me thats a trade that makes a lot of sense. If Peterka wants out of Buffalo its hard to find a better spot than riding shotgun with Mac. Meanwhile Buffalo wants another center and Necas wants to be a center
 
This morning on NHL Radio Scott Laughlin (morning show host) said he heard on a "reputable podcast" that Peterka for Necas is a real possibility. Anyone hear the podcast he's referring to?

To me thats a trade that makes a lot of sense. If Peterka wants out of Buffalo its hard to find a better spot than riding shotgun with Mac. Meanwhile Buffalo wants another center and Necas wants to be a center
Necas would have to fully agree to an extension first. So it couldn't be before July 1.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JKG33
Tampa is by and large the same way, most of their moves come out of left field. For instance, nobody brought up Bjorkstrand and Tampa, there wasn’t even a hint that Sergachev was going anywhere, then the McDonagh trade was also totally random.

Thing is, I’ve heard a lot about TB-Buf lately, with Tuch at the deadline and Peterka now. Wonder where it’s coming from


Sabres fired Tim Murray becausr one of his assistants was a leak. Owner said fired him. Tim Murray said no. He got fired.

Sabres are not the ones leaking dyuff

What you hrard is tampa likes to acquirr young players thst are on other teams.
This morning on NHL Radio Scott Laughlin (morning show host) said he heard on a "reputable podcast" that Peterka for Necas is a real possibility. Anyone hear the podcast he's referring to?

To me thats a trade that makes a lot of sense. If Peterka wants out of Buffalo its hard to find a better spot than riding shotgun with Mac. Meanwhile Buffalo wants another center and Necas wants to be a center
Not true at all.

Buffalo actually had a deal in place for Necas but he wouldn't negotiate s long term contrsct when he was an RFA. That killed the deal.

It will cost alot more than a 1 yr unsigned rental player to get Peterka.necas would have to agree on an extension
 
Not true at all.

Buffalo actually had a deal in place for Nrcas but he wouldn't negotiate s long term contrsct. That killed the deal.

It will cost alot more than a 1 yr unsigned rental player to get Peterka
Good to know. Was that last summer?

Gotta wonder wtf Necas wants. Didn't re-sign in Carolina because he wants to be a C. Likely ditto for Colorado. Buffalo would almost certainly give him a shot at C but he said no? Must wanna walk right to UFA
 
Good to know. Was that last summer?

Gotta wonder wtf Necas wants. Didn't re-sign in Carolina because he wants to be a C. Likely ditto for Colorado. Buffalo would almost certainly give him a shot at C but he said no? Must wanna walk right to UFA
Well, at the time, it looked like Buffalo had a top 6 centers in Tage Thompson and Dylan Cozens. Tage has been pretty permanently moved to wing, and Cozens was flipped for a center that averages about 50 games per season. The #1 C role in Buffalo is firmly up for grabs in a way that it was not last season. That has to be part of the calculus. Also, maybe Buffalo is just flat desperate and willing to gamble on Necas either changing his mind, or getting a huge haul at the deadline?

Who knows, but it seems plausible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JKG33
From what have heard from the actual player, I’m pretty sure what Peterka wants more than anything is a big long-term contract.

He’s a kid from Munich, so I can see him preferring another vibe to Buffalo in terms of cities.

But he has shown no outward signs of being unhappy with the team itself or his role on it, or of his priority being “I want out”.
Since when did Munich become a thriving Metropolis ? :laugh: It's certainly not Berlin.
Homesick is usually something 16 year olds have at summer camp.
 
Well, at the time, it looked like Buffalo had a top 6 centers in Tage Thompson and Dylan Cozens. Tage has been pretty permanently moved to wing, and Cozens was flipped for a center that averages about 50 games per season. The #1 C role in Buffalo is firmly up for grabs in a way that it was not last season. That has to be part of the calculus. Also, maybe Buffalo is just flat desperate and willing to gamble on Necas either changing his mind, or getting a huge haul at the deadline?

Who knows, but it seems plausible.
Ah, I thought even a year or two ago both Thompson and Cozens were in the purgatory of are they / aren't they a C or W. But i guess depending when this was ya'll mightve still had Mitts too.

Turning an RFA Peterka into what could be a 1st+prospect rental value that an unsigned Necas would return in March 2026 seems like bad value.

But if Buffalo is willing to back up the brinks truck for Necas I could see this deal. Buffalo should be after a hockey trade not selling Peterka for more magic beans.
 
Ah, I thought even a year or two ago both Thompson and Cozens were in the purgatory of are they / aren't they a C or W. But i guess depending when this was ya'll mightve still had Mitts too.

Turning an RFA Peterka into what could be a 1st+prospect rental value that an unsigned Necas would return in March 2026 seems like bad value.

But if Buffalo is willing to back up the brinks truck for Necas I could see this deal. Buffalo should be after a hockey trade not selling Peterka for more magic beans.
It's certainly bad value, but I wonder if Buffalo thinks it's a good gamble? Since the downside recoups a few assets while the upside is a bonafide NHL 1st line player.
 
Good to know. Was that last summer?

Gotta wonder wtf Necas wants. Didn't re-sign in Carolina because he wants to be a C. Likely ditto for Colorado. Buffalo would almost certainly give him a shot at C but he said no? Must wanna walk right to UFA
It was last summers. Necas was an RFA. He had 2 yrs of team control. Carolina signed him to 2 yr contract.

If he had had signed he'd likely got 2C time on sabres

Thr other issue is he wants to get paid as a center but is he a center?
 
Necas would have to fully agree to an extension first. So it couldn't be before July 1.
This is how Sabre fans get 30 pages of low ball offers. Your head is in the right place but Pegula has f***ed everything so hard that a rebuild might actually be easier than getting a series of hockey trades done. Necas makes all the sense in the world but he isn't gonna sign that extension. There's gotta be at least a dozen other guys we can say this about
 
This is how Sabre fans get 30 pages of low ball offers. Your head is in the right place but Pegula has f***ed everything so hard that a rebuild might actually be easier than getting a series of hockey trades done. Necas makes all the sense in the world but he isn't gonna sign that extension
Yeah, I changed my mind on that in the post above. Could be the team is willing to take exactly this kind of gamble to get themselves out of roster hell.
 
Yeah, I changed my mind on that in the post above. Could be the team is willing to take exactly this kind of gamble to get themselves out of roster hell.
Make the trade for Necas and cross your fingers he doesn't leave? Yeah. That might be the only way. And if Necas does leave, let's hope it gives Pegula more proper cause to piss off. I didn't think it could get worse than Hugh Culverhouse owning the Bucs and this is getting close
 
This morning on NHL Radio Scott Laughlin (morning show host) said he heard on a "reputable podcast" that Peterka for Necas is a real possibility. Anyone hear the podcast he's referring to?

To me thats a trade that makes a lot of sense. If Peterka wants out of Buffalo its hard to find a better spot than riding shotgun with Mac. Meanwhile Buffalo wants another center and Necas wants to be a center

A Necas trade to Buffalo was already stopped because he wouldn't sign an extension last summer, why would that change now?
 
A Necas trade to Buffalo was already stopped because he wouldn't sign an extension last summer, why would that change now?
As a Buffalo fan noted above, back then they had Thompson and Cozens as centers. Now Thompson is a winger and Norris is only available for 50ish games a season.

Maybe Necas reconsider given the above, and now being on his 2nd good team that doesnt see him as a C. He may realize he needs to lower his expectations re quality of team, if he wants to be a C.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BHD
Good to know. Was that last summer?

Gotta wonder wtf Necas wants. Didn't re-sign in Carolina because he wants to be a C. Likely ditto for Colorado. Buffalo would almost certainly give him a shot at C but he said no? Must wanna walk right to UFA
There is a 1C spot open in Buffalo now and there wasn't before.

I am not sure why that would change his mind though.
 
A Necas trade to Buffalo was already stopped because he wouldn't sign an extension last summer, why would that change now?

If the thing he cares most about is what role he plays on the team, Buffalo’s roster has changed in meaningful ways since then with Thompson being moved to wing and Cozens being swapped for Norris. There’s a lot more opportunity at center now, if that’s something that’s important to Necas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BHD
From what have heard from the actual player, I’m pretty sure what Peterka wants more than anything is a big long-term contract.

He’s a kid from Munich, so I can see him preferring another vibe to Buffalo in terms of cities.

But he has shown no outward signs of being unhappy with the team itself or his role on it, or of his priority being “I want out”.

Munich is a medium sized city that is relatively conservative in some ways. It's also a city based around a robust manufacturing economy. I'm curious what kind of city, that is not Buffalo or a similar city, that you think he would like to live in?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ValJamesDuex
There is a 1C spot open in Buffalo now and there wasn't before.

I am not sure why that would change his mind though.
Theres probably a very short list of teams desperate enough to want to pay him the money he wants and play him at C. Buffalo would almost certainly be one of them
 
From what have heard from the actual player, I’m pretty sure what Peterka wants more than anything is a big long-term contract.

He’s a kid from Munich, so I can see him preferring another vibe to Buffalo in terms of cities.

But he has shown no outward signs of being unhappy with the team itself or his role on it, or of his priority being “I want out”.
I think that most players want to get out of situations that look to be dysfunctional. The morale on a perpetual loser like BUF has to be very low. If they are on a contending team, players would play on the moon. Blaming the city of Buffalo for his wanting to get out is missing the forest for the trees.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Barsky

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad