Seravalli: - Buffalo may not have a choice but to trade Peterka | Page 20 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Seravalli: Buffalo may not have a choice but to trade Peterka

The ask was 4x 1sts for Eichel.

He was traded for 3x 1sts and a 2nd.

Eichel was traded for a 1st, a 2nd, a former 1st round pick, and a top 6 winger coming off major surgery. And they had to send back a 3rd.

I'm not sure Krebs, Tuch (On the IR at the time), and a 2nd for 3rd pick swap gets you a single first at the time of the trade. Certainly not 2 1st rounders.

Of all of Adams bumbles, the Eichel bumble might have been the worst. How it was handled from start to finish is a playbook on how not to deal with an unhappy player.
 
Eichel was traded for a 1st, a 2nd, a former 1st round pick, and a top 6 winger coming off major surgery. And they had to send back a 3rd.

I'm not sure Krebs, Tuch (On the IR at the time), and a 2nd for 3rd pick swap gets you a single first at the time of the trade. Certainly not 2 1st rounders.

Of all of Adams bumbles, the Eichel bumble might have been the worst. How it was handled from start to finish is a playbook on how not to deal with an unhappy player.
I’m not going to rehash this particular debate aside from saying I do not agree with your take on it.
 
Eichel
Reinhart
Hagel
Cozens
Ullmark
Peterka
Byrum

Assuming the last 2 come to fruition (obviously nothing is certain), that's just an absurd amount of talent to hemorrhage in a short period of time.
Eichel-- injured, wanted surgery contract insurance would not cover.

Reinhart--1 yr to UFA. Why didnt priir GM sign him to an 8 yr contract is a mystery

Prior GM didnt want to sign Hagel

Cozens was trsded for a true C in norris

Ullmark-- UFA j-- he was a big injury risk in buffalo constantly missing 3+ months. He showed talent when healthy

Byram acquired for Mitts.



Pulock for Peterka?
Not even close.
You can offer McDavid and Buffalo fans will say no
McDavid signed many things are available except for dahlin.
Borgen
Trocheck
Jones
12OA

for
Peterka
Sabes 2026 1st unprotected

Trochrck is a cso dump
Botgen is an overpaid bottom pair
jones is nothing special

These and 25 1st doesnt get Peterka alone 0
It would really depend on what direction the sabres are wanting to go.
A 1st, 2nd, Sawyer Mynio, Dakota Joshua?
A 2nd and Lekkerimakki, Joshua?
Nucks have other guys like Mancini and Willander but potential top pairing RHDs or even an high-end #3 is a lot to give up for a winger unless it's a more established guy like Robertson in Dallas.

You have to give to get.

Id ask for Wilander, Dakota, and unprotected 26 1st
The thing is as well is the sabres played no defense and I do wonder if their players would score as much on teams that play a solid system where defence isn't optional?

Not saying that's a for sure thing but it's something that has to be considered, especially with young players.

It wasnt a no defense issue.

Brief history...

22/23-- Buffalo ended just out of the playoffs. They had a top quarter PP.what hurt them was an 0-8-0 run where 5 of their 6 D missed games with 3+ out each game. They go 1-6-1 they make the plao
yoffs.

23/24 granato does focus on D. They improve GA butPP rank tanks to bottom quartile. Also doesn't help when they had a similar 10 game stretch where 4 of their top 6F were out. Offense production across the board drop. In advanced team stats they were equal or better than TB in all except PP and PK. TB was a playoff team.

24/25. Ruff is new coach. They went through a 0-10-4 stretch late nov- dec that killed them. Dahlin was out for galf of the games at least. Later in the season they had another losing skid of around 0-5-1. Outside of these dtresjs they have a solid playoff team record. These are just some data outliers from this season

1. 0-5-3 in games they had 2+ g lead. The 3 OT loses came on last minute pulled goalie goals they thrn lost in OT.
2. About 75% if their loses they led, tied, down 1g in 3rd with many 0'for # on PP.
.they take 10 of these to OT and W 5, that's 15 pts and puts them squarely in WC chase
3. Near top of league in 5v5 and 1st period scoring
4.also near the top in loses in games when they either scored first or had an anytime one goal lead

They maintain the scoring at 5v5, improve PP, improve PK. And improve some on team D and they are a pkayoff team


I don't see them moving peterks unless they get a deal they like or someone signs him to a 1+2+3 OS or more comp. Buffalo can replace peterka with their internal prospects/ players

Their roster st F without Peterka

XXX- NORRIS'THKMPSON
ZUCKER-XXX-QUINN
GREENWAY-MCLEOD-TUCH
MALENSTYN-KOZAK- KREBS
LAFERTY

.they also have Benson and Kulich. Kulich can play C orW, Thompson can play C or W. They could acquire a vet 2 yr short term 2C/W
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Legend123
It’s why you can’t really have a fair discussion because most BUF fans think this.
Honestly I understand selling high on JJ Peterka, he's a young 1st liner and the price should be really high but it need to be realistic.

I wish Montreal could land him but he's probably too expensive.
 
Refocusing the discussion- Peterka should stay, because he’s good. Quinn can go, because he isn’t.

Makin moves, I am.
I know everyone wants to move off of Quinn, I just don't see the point. He had back to bad major injuries and struggled like most people. He is not getting you anything good in a trade. The upside is still there as a top 6 player.
 
Eichel was traded for a 1st, a 2nd, a former 1st round pick, and a top 6 winger coming off major surgery. And they had to send back a 3rd.

I'm not sure Krebs, Tuch (On the IR at the time), and a 2nd for 3rd pick swap gets you a single first at the time of the trade. Certainly not 2 1st rounders.

Of all of Adams bumbles, the Eichel bumble might have been the worst. How it was handled from start to finish is a playbook on how not to deal with an unhappy player.

Krebs probably not. But Tich definitely would have. Powerforwards always cost a lot.
 
Huh? When the hell was the last time a hockey player, especially a young one, sat out an entire year? He is an RFA, if he wants to play hockey the Sabres can make sure it's for Buffalo. Dude isn't so unhappy he wants to stop playing hockey and make no money lol. Sabres say here is 7x7 take it or sit out. They can match any OS and say too bad. This is not a third contract or long term deal gone bad situation. An agent wants this narrative to attract offer sheets, which makes his client happy, and the agent happy. Classic agent negotiating through media.
Only thing I can think Peterka can do is sign an OS that walks him right to UFA.
 
I know everyone wants to move off of Quinn, I just don't see the point. He had back to bad major injuries and struggled like most people. He is not getting you anything good in a trade. The upside is still there as a top 6 player.

He looked fine in his return at the end of last season, had a whole healthy offseason, and just looked worse this season. Missed a team meeting.

Idk, I’m just reading the tea leaves there, and I don’t see the fire on ice either.

When I think of identity and the two soft dudes who we could lose- I’d package Quinn and Power for a solid RD, personally.

Peterka stays, sorry bud.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SECRET SQUIRREL
Eichel-- injured, wanted surgery contract insurance would not cover.

Reinhart--1 yr to UFA. Why didnt priir GM sign him to an 8 yr contract is a mystery

Prior GM didnt want to sign Hagel

Cozens was trsded for a true C in norris

Ullmark-- UFA j-- he was a big injury risk in buffalo constantly missing 3+ months. He showed talent when healthy

Byram acquired for Mitts.




Not even close.

McDavid signed many things are available except for dahlin.


Trochrck is a cso dump
Botgen is an overpaid bottom pair
jones is nothing special

These and 25 1st doesnt get Peterka alone 0


You have to give to get.

Id ask for Wilander, Dakota, and unprotected 26 1st


It wasnt a no defense issue.

Brief history...

22/23-- Buffalo ended just out of the playoffs. They had a top quarter PP.what hurt them was an 0-8-0 run where 5 of their 6 D missed games with 3+ out each game. They go 1-6-1 they make the plao
yoffs.

23/24 granato does focus on D. They improve GA butPP rank tanks to bottom quartile. Also doesn't help when they had a similar 10 game stretch where 4 of their top 6F were out. Offense production across the board drop. In advanced team stats they were equal or better than TB in all except PP and PK. TB was a playoff team.

24/25. Ruff is new coach. They went through a 0-10-4 stretch late nov- dec that killed them. Dahlin was out for galf of the games at least. Later in the season they had another losing skid of around 0-5-1. Outside of these dtresjs they have a solid playoff team record. These are just some data outliers from this season

1. 0-5-3 in games they had 2+ g lead. The 3 OT loses came on last minute pulled goalie goals they thrn lost in OT.
2. About 75% if their loses they led, tied, down 1g in 3rd with many 0'for # on PP.
.they take 10 of these to OT and W 5, that's 15 pts and puts them squarely in WC chase
3. Near top of league in 5v5 and 1st period scoring
4.also near the top in loses in games when they either scored first or had an anytime one goal lead

They maintain the scoring at 5v5, improve PP, improve PK. And improve some on team D and they are a pkayoff team


I don't see them moving peterks unless they get a deal they like or someone signs him to a 1+2+3 OS or more comp. Buffalo can replace peterka with their internal prospects/ players

Their roster st F without Peterka

XXX- NORRIS'THKMPSON
ZUCKER-XXX-QUINN
GREENWAY-MCLEOD-TUCH
MALENSTYN-KOZAK- KREBS
LAFERTY

.they also have Benson and Kulich. Kulich can play C orW, Thompson can play C or W. They could acquire a vet 2 yr short term 2C/W
McDavid not enough for dahlin??

Jeez

😆 🤣
 
I have this thought in my head. Not sure how it works on both sides here, but I'm trying to be reasonable and not emotional or attached. Basic 3 for 3 thing here.

Peterka
Samuelsson
Ostlund

--------

Weegar
Coleman
Basha
 
I have this thought in my head. Not sure how it works on both sides here, but I'm trying to be reasonable and not emotional or attached. Basic 3 for 3 thing here.

Peterka
Samuelsson
Ostlund

--------

Weegar
Coleman
Basha
I'm just an unreasonable, stupid loser Sabres fan, but yes, this works for me. I'd add as well.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad