Frederic is an interesting one. Big bodied, chirpy, secondary 5 on 5 finisher that doesn't create his own offense and doesn't help on special teams. The previous two seasons he is within one or two 5 on 5 goals as Necas, Boeser, DeBrincat, Marchand, Crouse, and Jarvis. That's a great asset to have on your third line and the kind of pickup that does actually work at the deadline. But this season his production has plummeted on a team that just doesn't have enough speed and skill to create offensive opportunities for him to finish. And if he is not finishing and not adding to special teams he is just a good fourth liner. If he was producing like the last two seasons, I don't think asking a 1st from a contender is out of the question at all. But, he isn't producing like that. But, he is only 26 and there are obvious reasons for why he is not producing when you look at the Bruins roster. But, it doesn't change the fact he isn't producing. Going to be interesting, but I'd put money on something equivalent to a 2nd.
Geekie is nice in that he is an RFA that can play all three positions anywhere in the top 9 and go out and score 20 goals without PP time. 15 goals over his last 30 games since being put with Pasta. Again, a valuable finishing piece to a contender, but unless a team projects him as more than someone who can leech off a star like Pasta, seems like more of a 2nd round kind of thing.
Coyle scored 60 points last year in a defensive role. This year he is pacing for half that. He is 32, so there is more suspicion around his big drop than with Frederic. And he has another year of term. Another guy that you could have netted a first for if he was playing like last year, but at his salary and age and him having another year of term left, the risk that his production fall off is age related instead of team related is just too great to get value back. Closer to having to pay to move him that getting anything back. Which is such a shame and surprise after he had such a great year last year. Coyle going into the shitter, Elias Lindholm being a bust (although rumors of him playing thru something give hope that it isn't a 7 year bust), Hampus Lindholm getting hurt and Swayman starting so slow after the contract stuff are huge pieces as to why the Bruins season sunk. Bruins getting any value for the guy that helped sink their season isn't realistic.
Carlo should a good return if he was dealt. He has struggled a bit this year with Hampus Lindholm being hurt, but is still above water on a bad team getting a lot of defensive minutes. He wants to be the #2 on a pairing not the #1 and he has had to be the pairing leader in Boston this year with Lindholm out. He is too one way of a player to lead a pairing. But 28 year old big top 4 RD with a career +130 playing hard hard minutes is a super super super valuable piece for a contender. And his 4.1 AAV over the next two years makes it even better. This is one that the Bruins would need some convincing to move on from as they would add a 2RD to their list of holes in addition to really having to re-work the forward group. Hard to do that when Pasta is in his prime still. I think it would take a 1st or a couple 2nds if the first was too high.
Marchand would be your standard 1st + prospect kind of deal if he ever made it to market with the market dictating the quality of the prospect.