I don't think scorched Earth is an option. They have too many high-priced contracts, with players good enough to not be a cellar dweller, but not good enough to legitimately do any damage. Sure, Pasta, McAvoy and Swayman are great players, but the surrounding cast is pedestrian. E. Linhdolm, is drastically overpaid for what he really is. Playing with Gaudreau and Tkachuk led to inflated numbers he hasn't come close to reproducing without them. Middlestadt is not a top 6 center, something Buffalo and Colorado realized. At 26, he is what he is. Zacha may be on a reasonable contract, but if he's your number one center, you're in trouble.
They remind me of the Habs teams of the late '90's - 2020. Good to great goaltending with a few high caliber players (they never had a pasta caliber player, true), and absolute crap center depth. They had a few good runs, but realistically were always a bubble team. Rarely bad enough to get a top draft pick (from 1985 to 2022 , their top picks were #3 in 2012 and 2018 and #5 in 2005) and never good enough to contend. They kept applying bandaids never embracing a true rebuild until a few years ago. This is best position they've been in since 1993, considering what they have and what's soon to come.
At the end of the day, I suspect they'll try the 'retool' approach, but unless they really hit on their draft picks (like they did on Bergeron and Pasta), they're stuck in mediocrity for the foreseeable future.