Apparently, according to @LeafsNation75So Hischier > Barzal too then by that logic?
Love Matthews but not sure he's at #10 just yet. Kopitar was a 92 point selke winner, he certainly belongs on this list.
how can a guy be the best scorer at ES by a lot (tied with mcdavid in 20 less games), be good in his own end, be good on the dot...and not be top 10?
One is the Hart winner and the other is?Should Matthews or Hall be the one off the list? That's another question.
This is Leafnation75's logic. People are pointing out the double standard.So Hischier > Barzal too then by that logic?
Giroux is better than all of them offensively, better than all but Kopi defensively. Better than all 3 overallKopitar or Tavares or MacKinnon, Matthews being in the top ten is a joke.
Guy has 6 top 10 scoring finishes and 3 top 5 scoring finishes and has the 2nd most points this decade and last season.maybe they arent ignoring his 14g/58pt/-15 season the year before
because that doesnt even put him in the top 100. monster last year obviously, but he needs to put up 90+ again to get in the top 10 convo
Soooo.... You're trying to say Giroux, coming off a 102 point season with 5 seasons scoring much higher than Matthew's best year, while being much better defensively isn't top 10, but Matthews is?how can a guy be the best scorer at ES by a lot (tied with mcdavid in 20 less games), be good in his own end, be good on the dot...and not be top 10?
His base line (average) is higher than any player in this poll.Giroux is an odd duck. Great season last year no doubt, but the two years before were incredibly disappointing. Is he just riding a ridiculous PDO-like wave or is he now a 90+ point player after three seasons of sub PPG rates?
I can see a lot of buyer beware with a 30 year old putting up a season that's so far out of line with what you came to expect his baseline to be.
I'd take Kane over Hall everyday of the week.
Giroux isn't better than MacKinnon offensively.Giroux is better than all of them offensively, better than all but Kopi defensively. Better than all 3 overall
maybe they arent ignoring his 14g/58pt/-15 season the year before
because that doesnt even put him in the top 100. monster last year obviously, but he needs to put up 90+ again to get in the top 10 convo