Best Lineup But Only 1 Player Per Team

[Maraz]

I guess there already was thread like this and if so I am sorry but i had that idea to make the best 23 MEN LINE-UP (13F, 7D, 3G) while picking only ONE PLAYER PER TEAM while also logically you must EXCLUDE NINE TEAMS and not pick any player from their rosters. Basically NHL All-Star picks but make them one line-up and cut some.
Sounds pretty easy but turned out to be quite challenging especially when you need to skip some of the best players in the league.

My attempt:

Kaprizov-McDavid-Kucherov
Hughes-Crosby-Pastrnak
Aho-Eichel-Marner
Stutzle-Barkov-Kempe
Konecny

Hughes-Fox
Josi-Makar
Werenski-Heiskanen
Dahlin

Hellebuyck, Sorokin, Dostal

exclude: DET, MTL, WSH, CHI, SJS, SEA, STL, CGY, UTA

(not ideal and had hard time deciding some teams and players - Ovi/Colorado..)

Click to read more...

 

[Mr Kot]

Would this be able to beat a Monstars alien team?

 

[Akrapovince]

Would be hard for me to pass up on Matthews here but also can’t go wrong with Marner.

 

[Maraz]

Would this be able to beat a Monstars alien team?

Had to google what that is cause I grew up in mid 90s Slovakia and didnt have access to that kind of entertaintment

 

[Mitch nylander]

Auston Matthews - Connor Mcdavid - Nikita Kucherov
Kirill Kaprizov - J. Hughes - David Pastrnak
Aleksander Barkov - Sidney Crosby - Mark Stone
Alex Ovechkin - Anze Kopitar - Tage Thompson
Connor Bedard, Travis Konecny

Quinn Hughes - Cale Makar
Roman Josi - Adam Fox
Zach Werenski - Miro Heiskanen
Jaccob Slavin

Conor Hellebuyck
Ilya Sorokin
Linus Ullmark

Edit : Took 2 sens, swapped Tkachuk for Bedard, and moved Ovi to the "heavy 4th line".

Spoiler: Choices

Anaheim- N/A
Boston - Mcavoy
Buffalo - Thompson
Calgary - N/A
Carolina - Slavin
Chicago - Bedard
Colorado - Makar
Columbus - Werenski
Dallas - Heiskanen
Detroit - N/A
Edmonton - Mcdavid
Florida- Barkov
LA - Kopitar
Minnesota - Kaprizov
Montreal - N/A
Nashville - Josi
NJ - Jack Hughes
NYI - Sorokin
NYR - Fox
Ottawa - Ullmark
Pittsburgh - Crosby
Philadelphia - Konecny
Seattle - N/A
San Jose - N/A
St Louis - N/A
Tampa - Kucherov
Toronto - Matthews
Vancouver- Q. Hughes
Utah - N/A
Vegas - Stone
Washington - Ovechkin
Winnipeg - Hellebuyck

 

[Akrapovince]

Auston Matthews - Connor Mcdavid - Nikita Kucherov
Kirill Kaprizov - J. Hughes - David Pastrnak
Aleksander Barkov - Sidney Crosby - Mark Stone
Brady Tkachuk - Anze Kopitar - Tage Thompson
Alex Ovechkin

Quinn Hughes - Cale Makar
Roman Josi - Adam Fox
Zach Werenski - Miro Heiskanen
Jaccob Slavin

Conor Hellebuyck
Ilya Sorokin
Linus Ullmark


Anaheim- N/A
Boston - Mcavoy
Buffalo - N/A
Calgary - N/A
Carolina - Slavin
Chicago - N/A
Colorado - Makar
Columbus - Werenski
Dallas - Heiskanen
Detroit - N/A
Edmonton - Mcdavid
Florida- Barkov
LA - Kopitar
Minnesota - Kaprizov
Montreal - N/A
Nashville - Josi
NJ - Jack Hughes
NYI - Sorokin
NYR - Fox
Ottawa - Ullmark
Pittsburgh - Crosby
Philadelphia - N/A
Seattle - N/A
San Jose - N/A
St Louis - N/A
Tampa - Kucherov
Toronto - Matthews
Vancouver- Q. Hughes
Utah - N/A
Vegas - Stone
Washington - Ovechkin
Winnipeg - Hellebuyck

Lmfao that Barkov - Crosby - Stone line would be just plain stupid to watch.

 

[Mitch nylander]

Lmfao that Barkov - Crosby - Stone line would be just plain stupid to watch.

Nobody is scoring on it ever.

 

[Horvat1C]

McDavid - Crosby - Kaprizov
Matthews - Eichel - Kucherov
B. Tkachuk - Barkov - J. Hughes
Aho - Suzuki - Barzal
Larkin, Konecny

Q. Hughes - Makar
Josi - Heiskanen
Werenski - McAvoy
Sergachev

Shesterkin
Hellebuyck

 

[Clint Eastwood]

B. Tkachuk - McDavid - Kucherov
Kaprizov - Matthews - M. Tkachuk
Forsberg - Crosby - Barzal
J. Hughes - Kopitar - Stone
Thompson

Heiskanen - Makar
Q. Hughes - McAvoy
Slavin - Fox
Seider

Hellebuyck
Dostal
Wolf

Excluded CBJ, CHI, MTL, PHI, SJ, SEA, STL, UTAH, WSH

Did the defense first and then filled in the rest. Made sure my forwards had some grimey assholes in the mix too to make hell for all opposition.

Fun exercise.

 

[These Are The Days]

We might not see an actual 3rd or 4th line anywhere in these lineups

 

[Took a pill in Sbisa]

Kaprizov-McDavid-Kucherov
Ovechkin-Barkov-Marner
B. Tkachuk-Crosby-Konecny
Aho-Eichel-Kempe

Heiskanen-Makar
Q. Hughes-Fox
Dahlin-McAvoy

Hellebyuck
Saros

Trying to consider putting players in their usual positions and somewhat playing style matching

 

[FunkySeeFunkyDo]

Poor Mackinnon. He’s Esposito to Makar’s Orr.

 

[Mitch nylander]

I think this exercise is more fun with prospects! Maximum 30 NHL game.

Danila Yurov (MIN) - Dalibor Dvorsky (STL) - Ivan Demidov (MTL)
Gabe Perreault (NYR) - Berkley Catton (SEA) - Ryan Leonard (WSH)
Danil But (UTA) - Cayden Lindstrom (CBJ) - Beckett Sennecke (ANA)
Isak Rosen (BUF) - Brad Lambert (WPG) - Easton Cowan (TOR)
Matthew Savoie (EDM)

Alexander Nikishin (CAR) - Artem Levshunov (CHI)
Anton Silayev (NJ) - Axel Sandin Pelikka (DET)
Lian Bichsel (DAL) - Zayne Parekh (CGY)
Carter Yakemchuk (OTT)

Yaroslav Askarov (SJ)
Igor Nabokov (COL)
Joel Blomqvist (PIT)

 

[DJN21]

How dare you pass on Hutson! Hes burgeoning so hard right now!

 

[zar]

I guess there already was thread like this and if so I am sorry but i had that idea to make the best 23 MEN LINE-UP (13F, 7D, 3G) while picking only ONE PLAYER PER TEAM while also logically you must EXCLUDE NINE TEAMS and not pick any player from their rosters. Basically NHL All-Star picks but make them one line-up and cut some.
Sounds pretty easy but turned out to be quite challenging especially when you need to skip some of the best players in the league.

My attempt:

Kaprizov-McDavid-Kucherov
Hughes-Crosby-Pastrnak
Aho-Eichel-Marner
Stutzle-Barkov-Kempe
Konecny

Hughes-Fox
Josi-Makar
Werenski-Heiskanen
Dahlin

Hellebuyck, Sorokin, Dostal

exclude: DET, MTL, WSH, CHI, SJS, SEA, STL, CGY, UTA

(not ideal and had hard time deciding some teams and players - Ovi/Colorado..)

Eichel-McDavid-Pastrnak
Kaprizov-Matthews- Kucherov
Forsberg-Barkov-Bedard
J.Hughes-Crosby-Kempe
Ovechkin, Raymond

Heiskanen-Makar
Q.Hughes-Fox
Werenski-Weegar
Dahlin

Hellebuyck-Ullmark
Sorokin

 

[boompuffboom]

Drai MacK Pasta
Willy Sid TW43
Laine Barkov Aho
Kopi TThompson Kiril

Fox DougiHam
Hughes Seider
Josi Heis
QH

Vasi, Helly

 

[Dr Pepper]

Ovechkin (WSH) - McDavid (EDM) - Marner (TOR)
B. Tkachuk (OTT) - Crosby (PIT) - M. Tkachuk (FLA)
Kaprizov (MIN) - Eichel (VGK) - Kucherov (TB)
Laine (MTL) - Celebrini (SJ) - Kempe (LA)

Makar (COL) - Josi (NSH)
Hughes (VAN) - Hughes (NJ)
Seider (DET) - Fox (NYR)

Hellebuyck (WPG)
Oettinger (DAL)
Swayman (BOS)

Excluded: St. Louis, Chicago, Utah, Seattle, Calgary, Philly, Columbus, NY Islanders, Carolina (damn, not a lot of love for the Metro I guess )

 

[TheDawnOfANewTage]

We might not see an actual 3rd or 4th line anywhere in these lineups

Ya, for some messed up reason I wanna see the worst nhl squad, 1 guy from each team who has played 30+ games, but is an absolute plug.

Cool concept OP, I’m just not sure I’m changing what ya did that much.

 

[nickdawg95]

Kaprizov-Mcdavid-Nylander
Connor-Mackinnon-Kucherov
B.Tkachuk-Eichel-Pastanak
Panarin-Barkov-crosby
Wilson

Hughes-weegar
Werenski-Slavin
Dahlin-Heiskanen
Sieder

Sorokin/Saros

 

[Il Stugotz]

I’d like to see some cap compliant lineups.
If I were posting from work I’d totally make one

 

[These Are The Days]

Ya, for some messed up reason I wanna see the worst nhl squad, 1 guy from each team who has played 30+ games, but is an absolute plug.

Cool concept OP, I’m just not sure I’m changing what ya did that much.

I live for that stuff. I may have to see what I come up with

 

[These Are The Days]

I'm gonna finish this later

I want a realistic lineup with ACTUAL shutdown lines and shutdown defense. The idea of rolling Crosby as 4th line wing is ridiculous. I am not making an all star team. I am making a team that would destroy your fantasy lineup in real life.

Otherwise my goal is to construct a team that is going to psychologically f***ing break you to prices and torment you for 60 minutes. They'll slash you after the whistle. They'll talk shit during a puck drop and ACTUALLY beat the f*** out of you. Oh you're gonna hate them



You people *THINK* you hated the 2010 Canucks and 2021 Lightning. That's gonna be funny once I figure this out

Kaprizov-McDavid-Kucherov
Marchand-Matthews-M. Tkachuk
-Gourde-
-Hintz-Wilson

Bedard

Slavin-Makar
Josi-Parayko
Gudas

Sergachev

Hellebuyck

 

[Coffee]

Auston Matthews - Connor Mcdavid - Nikita Kucherov
Kirill Kaprizov - J. Hughes - David Pastrnak
Aleksander Barkov - Sidney Crosby - Mark Stone
Alex Ovechkin - Anze Kopitar - Tage Thompson
Connor Bedard, Travis Konecny

Quinn Hughes - Cale Makar
Roman Josi - Adam Fox
Zach Werenski - Miro Heiskanen
Jaccob Slavin

Conor Hellebuyck
Ilya Sorokin
Linus Ullmark

Edit : Took 2 sens, swapped Tkachuk for Bedard, and moved Ovi to the "heavy 4th line".

Spoiler: Choices

Anaheim- N/A
Boston - Mcavoy
Buffalo - Thompson
Calgary - N/A
Carolina - Slavin
Chicago - Bedard
Colorado - Makar
Columbus - Werenski
Dallas - Heiskanen
Detroit - N/A
Edmonton - Mcdavid
Florida- Barkov
LA - Kopitar
Minnesota - Kaprizov
Montreal - N/A
Nashville - Josi
NJ - Jack Hughes
NYI - Sorokin
NYR - Fox
Ottawa - Ullmark
Pittsburgh - Crosby
Philadelphia - Konecny
Seattle - N/A
San Jose - N/A
St Louis - N/A
Tampa - Kucherov
Toronto - Matthews
Vancouver- Q. Hughes
Utah - N/A
Vegas - Stone
Washington - Ovechkin
Winnipeg - Hellebuyck

You can’t have Matthews- McDavid or Hughes-Makar on the same line, dude

 

[These Are The Days]

@The Macho King

Yo. This thread looks like your kind of speed. Constricting the heel lineup is going amazing right now

 

[Barry Amsterdam]

i’ll go arguably 2nd best player per team

B.Tkachuk Mackinnon M.Tkachuk
Connor Drasaitl Necas
Petterson Hischier Marner
Michkov Malkin Laine

Dobson Seider
Theodore Mcavoy
Doughty Faber

Vasilevsky
Shesterkin