Best American goalie of All-Time

[RedWingzz]

Who is the best American goalie of All-Time?

 

[rent free]

damian rhodes because he has 1 goal scored while the other american goalies all time have 0

 

[Voodoo Child]

Quick and Thomas has the highest highs, but Quick will have the longevity to add to what will be a hall of fame career...no quickies with him.

 

[GlitchMarner]

damian rhodes because he has 1 goal scored while the other american goalies all time have 0

Rhodes scored a goal? When?

 

[Lauro]

As ranked on the all-time goalie top 40 list on the history board:
.
9. Frank Brimsek
.
.
.
29. Tom Barrasso
34. John Vanbiesbrouck
37. Tim Thomas
.
NR: Quick, Richter, Miller

--> Shame on the OP!

 

[biturbo19]

Mike Richter. And i say that with a great deal of disdain as a Canucks fan. But a lot of respect for his play as a hockey fan.

 

[KirkAlbuquerque]

Thomas had that amazing short run, but im gonna go Richter

 

[NyQuil]

Tim Thomas.

He’s like USAs Hasek.

Maybe I still have PTSD from when he would dominate Ottawa for years.

 

[ecemleafs]

Brimsek. 2 time first team all star and 6 time 2nd team all star. 2 time vezina winner. 2 cups.

 

[amnesiac]

Brimsek

 

[JackSlater]

Brimsek is the only American goalie in the HHOF, and yet is not on the list. I pick Brimsek pretty comfortably over the others.

 

[tony d]

Other- Frank Brimsek. One of the best early goalies in the NHL.

 

[ESH]

There’s absolutely no way Richter should be winning this