Bennett hit on Stolarz (no supplemental discipline) MOD WARNING IN POST #621

[izlez]

You can read the paper yourself.

It’s perhaps you that should be embarrassed.

This is garbage.

You know how you hear 5 days a week on the local news "A new study shows...(insert completely world shattering thing that never gets spoken of again)"?

This is one group finding a potential trend and hyping the hell out of it. The paper itself says "a POTENTIAL new trend" and it is the only study ever referenced on the subject.

 

[ProjectPanthers]

Never said you were, just seems like a pointless thing to do... risk head injury to win Z division...

Again, it's not risking anything serious cause the contact isn't that bad, just like Stolarz's wasn't that bad.

That's what convinces me that he had issues before Bennett's contact. It just doesn't seem to be enough to warrant such a violent reaction with the vomiting and hospital visit. Glad to hear he's out.

 

[Clark4Ever]

It wasn't a vicious hit but it was still dirty, deliberate and totally unnecessary.

Bennett's history speaks for itself. The fact that he avoided supplementary discipline again just illustrates that he is very good at what he does.

 

[red devil]

 

[mobilus]

He barely touched him.

Most of the damage was done by the shot, or it was some sort of freak occurence.

Only Stolarz can answer that. You have zero idea outside of your own speculations.

 

[RedHawkDown]

This is garbage.

You know how you hear 5 days a week on the local news "A new study shows...(insert completely world shattering thing that never gets spoken of again)"?

This is one group finding a potential trend and hyping the hell out of it. The paper itself says "a POTENTIAL new trend" and it is the only study ever referenced on the subject.

The study was published last fall. It’s not even remotely surprising that it’s the first one reporting this given it was extremely recent lol.

Is this SHAAKE thing going to be validated by other groups? We will see. It’s hilarious though people in this thread acting like they are somehow scientific experts. This is exactly how symptoms of disease are discovered. Concussion is one that is very poorly understood.

The news sensationalizing other studies has absolutely nothing to do with this.

 

[notbias]

Glad Maurice is now on the side that thinks Bennett is a dirty player, only an idiot could watch all his hits and think otherwise...

 

[Bileur]

First of all, I wish Stolarz a speedy recovery. Hope he takes the time he needs. Don’t want to mess with a head injury.

On the play itself, I’d probably have given a 2 for interference but there doesn’t seem to be intent there. Not enough force.

The injury likely comes from a combination of the Reinhart shot and this. I don’t think you can really fault the concussion spotters either, Stolarz did give a head shake but that can mean anything. Just an unfortunate result.

Paul Maurice is one of the funniest coaches in the league.

 

[Cyclones Rock]

Upon further review, I have to change my mind about the play.



I think Button's explanation is correct. That being said, Bennett is still a dirt bag

 

[Panteras]

Justice served.
Now I’m going to have my microwave running all day making popcorn while I read this thread.

 

[notbias]

Upon further review, I have to change my mind about the play.



I think Button's explanation is correct. That being said, Bennett is still a dirt bag

It's three playoffs in a row where he has accidentally punched someone causing injury.

 

[dangomon]

You can read the paper yourself.

It’s perhaps you that should be embarrassed.

As someone who has spent their entire professional career studying head impacts I'd urge you to understand that a published paper =/= absolute truth. For reference this journal's impact factor is the bare minimum to be considered "Good" or "Reputable" (3 on a 0-10 scale).

SHAAKE has promise as a diagnostic tool, but has far too many confounding factors right now with imperfect and subjective reporting and analysis.

 

[BlueOil]

The study was published last fall. It’s not even remotely surprising that it’s the first one reporting this given it was extremely recent lol.

Is this SHAAKE thing going to be validated by other groups? We will see. It’s hilarious though people in this thread acting like they are somehow scientific experts. This is exactly how symptoms of disease are discovered. Concussion is one that is very poorly understood.

if you can question someone's motivation, it doesn't matter if you understand their research, or how research works, or how science works

doubt their character and make yourself looks smurt

 

[izlez]

So a couple questions:

1. Has it been confirmed anywhere that he was puking on the bench? Or is it solely based on the video of him leaning over the bench where it *looks* like he is *probably* puking?

2. Now that he has been to the hospital, has it been reported anywhere that he has been diagnosed with a concussion? Has it been reported anywhere that he was taken to the hospital for a suspected concussion?

 

[winnipegger]

If we want law of the jungle this is the way. Enforcers are rare nowadays but they were there for a reason. Players needed body guards. If the goalies need body guards this is going to get ugly. Should have given him a game for contacting the head. Even if it was accidental that's why it's only a 1 game, and he will be more careful or next one is 5 games. Use your goddamn authority to enforce the law so Ryan Reeves doesn't do it.

 

[River Meadow]

"Stolie"

Awwwwwwweeeeeeeeeee

 

[darrylsittler27]

Stolarz left the game after this. How many times does this guy need to "accidentally" hit someone in the head before the league actually does something? This is years of this crap by this guy.

He isn't a leaf. If he was there is no way they miss that call.

 

[ashs]

False. Kadri in fact did not get suspended for a much more malicious and intense contact that took Binnington out of the 2022 playoffs with an injury.

If he was a leaf he would have

 

[Kranix]

So a couple questions:

1. Has it been confirmed anywhere that he was puking on the bench? Or is it solely based on the video of him leaning over the bench where it *looks* like he is *probably* puking?

2. Now that he has been to the hospital, has it been reported anywhere that he has been diagnosed with a concussion? Has it been reported anywhere that he was taken to the hospital for a suspected concussion?

Are these questions directed at the unhinged Leafs fans trying to reverse engineer intent from injury?

 

[Golden_Jet]

It's three playoffs in a row where he has accidentally punched someone causing injury.

Mike Johnson called it a light bump today, not a punch. Said it should of been a 2 minute penalty,

 

[izlez]

The study was published last fall. It’s not even remotely surprising that it’s the first one reporting this given it was extremely recent lol.

Is this SHAAKE thing going to be validated by other groups? We will see. It’s hilarious though people in this thread acting like they are somehow scientific experts. This is exactly how symptoms of disease are discovered. Concussion is one that is very poorly understood.

The news sensationalizing other studies has absolutely nothing to do with this.

So I think we completely agree.

Its an initial study that suggests a hypothesis. I have an issue with people definitively claiming that shaking your head is definitively a symptom of a concussion, and proof of a concussion in this instance.

 

[SenzZen]

His son is the AGM of the Florida Panthers too.

lmao it's literally noted multiple times in the post you quoted

 

[notbias]

Mike Johnson called it a light bump today, not a punch. Said it should of been a 2 minute penalty,

That is very interesting, thank you for pointing that out, I will now no longer think for myself and take the opinion of Mike Johnson as fact, thank you again.

 

[Kranix]

If we want law of the jungle this is the way. Enforcers are rare nowadays but they were there for a reason. Players needed body guards. If the goalies need body guards this is going to get ugly. Should have given him a game for contacting the head. Even if it was accidental that's why it's only a 1 game, and he will be more careful or next one is 5 games. Use your goddamn authority to enforce the law so Ryan Reeves doesn't do it.

suspend a player 1 game for an accident?

 

[Kaner9]

lmao nhl discipline spin dat wheel