I would get the reflex to cast doubt over Reilly's play, but it's hackneyed now to do so with Marner this season and from last night's play.
As Leafs fans, we have a duty towards objective criticism, and the one defining criticism for Marner has been his value balanced against his goal output, especially in the playoffs. But he scored this time. Game 2 might provide legitimate ammo, but Game 1 didn't. What Game 1 provided was:
- Establishing a lead at home.
- Maintaining the lead with great goaltending and with emphatic response when the opposition scored.
- Discipline while Ottawa took dumb penalties and maximizing opportunity on special teams
- Contributions up and down the lineup from while absorbing Ottawa's shenanigans.
- Confidence in the Coach's ability to line match and respond with the right message at the right time.
- Going up 1-0 in the series and continuing momentum from the regular season results.
These are all VERY positive indicators, mindful there are a few moments where momentum could have shifted the other way. But they were few and far between and our responses demonstrated discipline.
I don't know, man...Doesn't this all (including Marner) feel
a bit different to you?