Mittelstadt was Buffalo's leading scorer despite 2way deployment. How is that a 3C?
Meanwhile, I can totally concede that Byram is capable of playing high event top pairing minutes on a bad team. Just because he's playing there in Buffalo doesn't mean he's already playing at the level of a "top pairing cailber" defender with any regularity though. Let's be clear that those are two distinctly different things.
Just want to back up this response. Mittelstadt has been on a steady upward trajectory for two seasons now. He was only considered a "3C" because of Thompson and Cozens having good stats last season while they 1) played pond hockey and 2) played with the best four wingers while Mittelstadt played mostly with Asplund and Olofsson, or sometimes Jost. This season Mitts played with Greenway and Benson mostly, and still led the team in pts while still playing the best two-way game of the FW group.Guy was also Buffalo’s #1 forward by almost a minute in even strength ice time per game. Almost a minute more than Alex Tuch at #2. Well over a minute more than Tage and over two minutes more than Cozens.
That’s not only not third line deployment, that’s top line deployment. Now talent-wise he's probably perceptively behind Tage and Cozens and one could definitely argue in the perfect Sabres world that never existed this season, he should've been #3 in terms of center depth but Tage and Cozens have been wildly inconsistent and ineffective at various points in the season and clearly, Sabres brass gravitated towards the consistent two-way effort of Mitts.
I'm not going to guess at who won this trade, but many fans think Buffalo had the C depth to afford trading Mitts. They really don't. Thompson and Cozens are flawed Cs trying too much thinking they are or should be 80+ pt players based on inflated numbers from last season. They have been possession holes while Mitts has been responsible, intelligent, and dogged on the puck. I don't know if the front office had to be cheap about his next contract or they just don't realize he's the best of the three, but they made a mistake in trading him. Savoie and Kulich do NOT project as NHL Cs, so that leaves Ostlund who is at least 3-4 years away from reaching his potential, if he even gets there. I'm sure Byram will be a fine/great player, but the Sabres C depth will not survive the hole left in Mitts' absence unless Kevyn Adams makes a very big move. Avs fans will be very happy with Mittelstadt, and I will remain in the dark abyss of being a Sabres fan.