I agree on Tlusty. The things that made him successful last year seem to be coming back. First in on the forecheck, getting to the right spots, skating hard, etc..
I disagree on Staal and Semin though. Semin's play last night (at least in the first half of the game) in the Canes zone was nonchalant at best, lazy at worst. Early in the first, he ices it because he doesn't skate two more strides before dumping it in the zone. Two or three times, the puck comes to him on the wing and he does a simple flick of his stick (or skate) to deflect it to the other team. No attempt to control it or get it out of the zone or, god forbid get an organized attack going the other way. Takes a lazy hooking penalty, etc... And at times when he does get the puck in the Canes zone, he goes off and skates circles and the other guys have no clue what he's doing.
He was ok in the neutral zone/offensive zone and he did backcheck hard, but his work in the own zone wasn't particularly good IMO. He also holds onto the puck WAY too long on the PP before trying an ill advised pass. Not putting this all on him as the rest of the guys on the unit are basically not moving their feet so other than passing it back to the guy who just passed it to him, there aren't many options.
And E. Staal we've discussed enough. He just looks slow and weak. Until late in the game, rarely won a board battle and rarely skated with any speed.
I know I'm being overly critical of these two, but when they are the only real threats the team has (especially with Skinner out), the team needs more from them.