Atlantic Standings Predictions Thread

Aurinko

Registered User
Apr 1, 2015
3,515
2,305
Finland
Montreal defense looks dreadful and the kids, while they are all over the place, they HAVE done it the right way and given a lot of chances to a lot of young players. Don't really think it will start paying dividends just yet, but it really is sort of exciting team. I would not be too surprised if they got a hot start or streak during the season and got close.
 

SheldonJPlankton

Registered User
Sponsor
Oct 30, 2006
2,897
1,868
"Still way too soft, weak, fragile, and heartless" implies that they haven't been able to be top two in their division in the past. 3 of the last 4 years they were top 2 in their division.

2nd in their division is the most likely. The question for the regular season is if they can improve their consistency and make a push for the division title to give themselves the best chance to finally have some playoff success.
Yeah, let's beat the drum on the North Division. 🤪 The Leafs shining moment as a division title winner before being pimped-slapped by the Habs in the first round.

The ship has sailed on those 115 and 111 point teams. It ain't coming back. 102 points last season and falling. Mediocrity is approaching on the horizon. They'll be lucky to finish third. With that questionable goaltending, they just might be wildcard contenders.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheOrangeDesk

DapperCam

Registered User
Jul 9, 2006
6,366
3,765
Florida
Toronto
Boston
Tampa Bay
Ottawa
Detroit
Montreal
Buffalo

I think unfortunately Buffalo will be in the last spot for a couple more years. I actually was thinking of putting Ottawa higher, but Tampa Bay in my view is safe in #4 spot.
Sabres haven't finished last in the Atlantic division since the 2017-2018 season. Why would they be in the last spot for the next couple of years? Do you think they've gotten worse?
 
  • Like
Reactions: wetcoast and bert

Dread Clawz

LAWSonic Boom
Nov 25, 2006
27,978
9,974
Pennsylvania
Montreal defense looks dreadful and the kids, while they are all over the place, they HAVE done it the right way and given a lot of chances to a lot of young players. Don't really think it will start paying dividends just yet, but it really is sort of exciting team. I would not be too surprised if they got a hot start or streak during the season and got close.

They will be an exciting young up and coming team in a couple years. But I don't see how they aren't last in the division yet again. Just not enough there on the roster in an incredibly tough division.
 

viper0220

Registered User
Oct 10, 2008
8,934
4,080
Almost all the posters have Ottawa outside of the playoffs, with them needing to forfeit the pick in the next 2 years, do they make any big trade to try and push themselves higher in the standings?
 

Wayfarer13

Registered User
Jun 21, 2020
506
219
They will be an exciting young up and coming team in a couple years. But I don't see how they aren't last in the division yet again. Just not enough there on the roster in an incredibly tough division.
Three points to consider. If CP and Monty replicate their numbers prorated would drop GA by about 36 goals. Caufeild,Suzuki and Slafkovsky scored 54 of their 81 goals in the last 41 games. Prorated for 82 games would be 104 goals giving an improvement of 49 goals on the goal differential. To add to this they may have an actual second line.
 
Last edited:

Dread Clawz

LAWSonic Boom
Nov 25, 2006
27,978
9,974
Pennsylvania
They are the oilers of 2014

Agreed, how Hutson, Demidov, and Hage turn out for them will be huge IMO. It seems like Slaf is on the right course, and Guhle and Xhekaj are promising pieces on the backend that have shown they will be pillars. Reinbacher is likely be become a top 4 D as well.
 

DKH

Worst Poster/Awful Takes
Feb 27, 2002
76,615
57,642
what boston has done pretty remarkble, half of ppl here been picking them for years to fall off for at least the last 5 years
In 2016 they said their run was over

They arguably have the best D/G group in league ~ certainly top 5

They are young in that area and Lohrei looks like a star which changes everything on that defense

Bruins defensive prospect group the shallowest and maybe/llikely overall skill at the bottom of the 32~ but to get Lohrei is like finding a mint Nolan Ryan rookie card at a yard sale
 
Last edited:

bert

Registered User
Nov 11, 2002
37,576
23,895
Visit site
I think Montreal will surprise a lot of people.

Dach & Dvorak (2 & 3 C) out basically all season. They didn’t have the depth to absorb that at all.

Pearson, Pezzetta, White, Ylonen and Stephens were all 35-42% xGF player which is ATROCIOUS and unacceptable for bottom 6 players, and they played a lot of minutes for us. We should get no minutes from them except maybe pezzetta.

In the bottom 6 RHP was injured early on and came back flat. Anderson has an outlier really bad year. Jake Evans played a lot of minutes in the middle 6 and he is overmatched there. 3 players who should improve easily on their 40% possession numbers playing on the 4th line.

Dvorak on a contract year and a long summer of getting back in shape. Should solidify the bottom 6.

PP underperformed a lot early on, but looked promising later in the year with the first line clicking.

Despite all this they had a close to flat goal differential 5v5 and 46 % xGF….

I think they are in the fight for one of the 2 WC spot.

1. Toronto
2. Florida
3. Boston
4. TB
5. Montreal
6. Buffalo
7. Detroit
8. Ottawa

A bit of a wish cast but I’ll stand by it!
Hahahaha Montreals fanbase is the least disconnected with reality on this entire site and its not remotely close. Trade rumor threads... check, prospect threads check, predictions check.

They're by far the worst team in the division. They over achieved last season by almost every statistical measure and were still terrible. Riding unsustainable goaltending and a new coach bump.

Dach and Dvorak as your 2/3 centers is not a net positive. You couldn't give Dvorak away for free. Dach is talented but inconsistent and injures all the time. Best case scenario and he's at best an average to below average #2.

There's nothing wrong with being bad in the middle of a rebuild. That's what they are in. It serves them best long term to get another top 5 pick anyway this season. Which they will.
 
Last edited:

Lshap

Hardline Moderate
Jun 6, 2011
28,148
27,311
Montreal
Hahahaha Montreals fanbase is the least disconnected with reality on this entire site and its not remotely close. Trade rumor threads... check, prospect threads check, predictions check.

They're by far the worst team in the division. They over achieved last season by almost every statistical measure and were still terrible. Riding unsustainable goaltending and a new coach bump.

Dach and Dvorak as your 2/3 centers is not a net positive. You couldn't give Dvorak away for free. Dach is talented but inconsistent and injures all the time. Best case scenario and he's at best an average to below average #2.

There's nothing wrong with being bad in the middle of a rebuild. That's what they are in. It serves them best long term to get another top 5 pick anyway this season. Which they will.
Luckily for Montreal, the standings aren't determined by your imagination.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DKH

redwings86

Registered User
Apr 15, 2024
641
162
Northern East
Predict:

Ottawa, Montreal, Tampa Bay and Florida to the Stanley Cup.

Montreal have more talented than Boston.

Montreal reach the goal the Stanley Cup.
 
Last edited:

DKH

Worst Poster/Awful Takes
Feb 27, 2002
76,615
57,642
Bruins are big and loaded

Can’t wait for this season

1. bruins
2. Florida
3. Tampa

the rest are soft or lack skill
 

Satanphonehome

Registered User
Jan 4, 2015
1,087
1,678
No they got worse, replacing Jeff Skinner with Jason Zucker makes them worse.

Jeff Skinner scored 24 goals last year that was a down year for him

The best Zucker ever did was 33 goals, Skinner has done that 5 times, and scored 31 as a rookie.

So you either downgraded from Skinner to Zucker.

OR you could see Zucker as the Oloffsson replacement which could be an upgrade, but if you do that, that means you didn't replace Skinner.

So you either replaced Skinner with Zucker

Or you didn't replace Skinner at all.

No matter how you look at that you got worse.

And no Jack Quinn by himself will not get you into the top 4.

Even if you accept Skinner is better than Zucker, this is a pretty narrow way of judging whether or not a team improved.

Last year’s Sabres had a team that played too soft, and too slow and lacked accountability.

Skinner is hardly a useless player, but he was the poster child for the above. And most of the other guys they moved on from were also lacking in one or more of those areas.

Incoming are five players who rank among the league’s fastest, three of which would have led last years Sabres team in hits.

And they brought in a veteran coach who preaches hard, fast and accountable.

I don’t know that the Sabres are any more skilled than they were last year, but this is a team that took some pretty serious steps to address its most obvious shortcomings.

They are significantly faster, harder and more accountable.
 

LEAFANFORLIFE23

Registered User
Jun 17, 2010
47,334
15,963
Even if you accept Skinner is better than Zucker, this is a pretty narrow way of judging whether or not a team improved.

Last year’s Sabres had a team that played too soft, and too slow and lacked accountability.

Skinner is hardly a useless player, but he was the poster child for the above. And most of the other guys they moved on from were also lacking in one or more of those areas.

Incoming are five players who rank among the league’s fastest, three of which would have led last years Sabres team in hits.

And they brought in a veteran coach who preaches hard, fast and accountable.

I don’t know that the Sabres are any more skilled than they were last year, but this is a team that took some pretty serious steps to address its most obvious shortcomings.

They are significantly faster, harder and more accountable.

You said they are faster, that's objectively true.

You said they are harder, that's objectively true.

You said they are more accountable with Lindy Ruff as their coach that's going to be objectively true.

You know what you didn't say? You didn't say that they were better,and I suspect I know why.

You said they were faster, harder and more accountable because you believe those things to be true, and I agree.

You did not say they are better, because they are not, and regardless of if you want to admit it or not you know it.

Even if they are better, and I don't think they are, but even if they are they aren't good enough to finish top 4 in the Atlantic and that's what It's going to take.

Which one of Toronto, Boston, Florida or Tampa are they overtaking? They aren't unless one of those teams suffer SEVERE injury and not just 1 either.

Truthfully I'm not convinced they are better than Ottawa or Detroit.

They are 5th in the Atlantic at best, 7th at worst
 

DougBodger

Registered User
Sep 24, 2023
67
68
Buffalo is the type of team that can make a huge jump with the same group.

Tons of untapped potential in guys who just hit the NHL the last few seasons in Quinn, Cozens, Peterka, Benson, Power, and Byram.

Add in Tage, Dahlin, and Tuch that is a team with a lot of talent + a revamped bottom 6.

Will they put it all together? Probably not, but if it hits it's going to hit big all at once.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad