I’m confused by reading some posts. Like if all this was really Dorion’s choice, like it was all “hockey decisions”; I mean why would he want to get rid of his best players that could have given him a chance to win NOW? My goal really wouldn’t be to defend Dorion because I’m not a fan and don’t think he was ready for this opportunity, but unfortunately the board narrative somewhat forces me to. I think people forget too quickly that the sens owner is Eugene Melnyk... This team is a relatively smaller market than others and from all appearances, Melnyk doesn’t seem to have the cash flow necessary to compete in the more and more expensive NHL with a forever rising salary cap (he’s also a total PR disaster and a shady character but that’s another subject)
This was not a rebuild because “we sucked, had an aging core and had no future”. Look at the age of the players that got sold for futures (picks/prospects almost entirely and when they acquired players; Brassard and Boedker; they had a lower salary than their cap hit instead of going for better expensive ones) : Karlsson, Zibanejad, Duchene, Stone, Dzingel, Hoffman. All in their prime; that’s enough talent to build a solid team around them; particularly when you have good prospects like Chabot, White, Brown, Batherson, Formenton,Wolanin, etc.
I believe Stone wanted to be part of what could have been a great team but the boat sank with Melnyk’s finances and he was the last casualty. Zibanejad was the first red flag but at the time, it was hard to know it would go this far. When EK was traded, it was the beginning of the end; how could Dorion convince the other core players in their prime to extend long term? The team was getting dismantled for no reason outside of financial reasons. If they wanted to keep all of them (even Zibanejad included); that would have been just too costly for Melnyk. Think spending to the cap, and eating money to get rid of Phaneuf and maybe Ryan contracts, etc. Things the rich markets do because they have to and want to give themselves the best chance possible.
What could have been? Stone could have still sign a “friendly deal”, use patience and embrace his leadership role and bring the next bunch of kids to the promise land but why wait when you could go contend right away for the money you deserve? He didn’t have to, simple as that