Filip Chytil
Registered User
- Mar 3, 2014
- 5,750
- 10,038

Avalanche Journal: Samuel Girard and the challenge of trading team-friendly contracts
Is Winnipeg Jets’ Neal Pionk a better hockey player than Colorado Avalanche’s Samuel Girard?

Another issue is the contract. Well, not his contract. At $5 million for two more seasons, a No. 3 defenseman who helps generate 5-on-5 offense and is a secondary helper on both special teams is a team-friendly pact.
For a team like the Avs — up against the cap and often looking to squeeze extra value out of its roster — trading a No. 3 defenseman on a team-friendly deal is a tough ask. Replacing him with a No. 3 guy of equal or better on-ice value could be cost-prohibitive.
The salary cap ceiling is finally going up in the NHL. And it will be way up relative to where it’s been for the past half decade.
Pionk wasn’t a $7 million defenseman last season. But next year, when the cap increases to $95.5 million, or keeps rising to $113.5 million in year three of his deal? Yeah, that number makes more sense.
Here’s the bottom line: It would be harder than fans think for the Avs to replace Girard. Not just because he’s a good player, but his contract was signed in a pre-cap spike world.
Those contracts are going to be even more valuable in the next couple of seasons. This isn’t just about Girard, either.
Pick another veteran outside the inner-circle core. Artturi Lehkonen? Valeri Nichushkin? Josh Manson?
They’re all signed to contracts that are very favorable to the Avs, given their production and value. Trying to replace any of them with a player of similar talent and value at a similar cost would be very difficult.
It will be next to impossible to do it in the free-agent market, because lots of teams now have lots of cap space. And while the Avs have made some nice trades in recent years, they are short on draft and prospect equity. So trading one of the players we’ve mentioned to fill a hole is one thing, but then making a second swap to replace the guy just shipped out will be hard as well.
Financially speaking, the Avs are stuck. It’s not as bad as that word suggests. When all of those players are healthy, the Avs are still an excellent hockey team. It’s a first-world problem by NHL standards.