First of all, I tap the signs around here.
2021 solid defender
View attachment 1030173
2022 solid defender
View attachment 1030176
2023 played with Braden Schneider
View attachment 1030177
2024 back to being a solid defender
View attachment 1030179
2025 a bit of an outlier
View attachment 1030180
I wouldn't call this wildly volatile.
There's a clear pattern outside of his offense in 2025. He's been solid with an average team, great with a great team, and dog shit playing with Schneider.
And generally...you're right. Lots of guys fluctuate wildly. They're complete passengers who react almost wholly to their teammates. This is not one of those guys. He's been good at defense and bad at offense, generally speaking, pretty consistently.