You know, just watching highlights for my review of overrated Oettinger last night and seeing what his recent extension was, now I’m not so shocked at what Blackwood got.
Realistically, Oettinger is probably worth about what Blackwood just got (maybe $6 million per) which would mean Blackwood is definitely worth less.
Oettinger is highly overrated though.
Swayman got the same deal Oettinger got and prior to Oettinger getting it. Swayman has been better than Oettinger (I know he’s not having a good year), but was doing it in a 1b tandem, while Oettinger has played a workhorse workload (by today’s standards) which is maybe the most flattering thing I can say for him. I don’t see him as elite.
There probably aren’t top-10 goalies anymore, just top-5. And I don’t at all see Oettinger as a top 5 goalie.