I don't understand how this isn't more controversial. The Vancouver media guys all have this credo about no longer being fans once they turn professional, no cheering in the pressbox, etc. Edmonton's media seems to operate like a collegiate or South American soccer club, and everyone just kind of accepts it? It'd be one thing if they were just kind of biased, but they're also observably over-the-top (worst thing ever, deserves a lifetime suspension), etc. Even the Edmonton guys affiliated with national media, like Mark Spector.
I'd say it's a smaller-town thing, but it's not like that here in Ottawa, for example.
Being in the market, I think most people see it as a good, if not
great thing about the local media. It's why people are willing to put up with (and sometimes even celebrate) absolute dinosaurs like Jim Matheson. And the moment someone like that steps out of line (ol' Matty's "Leon why are you so pissy" incident from a couple years back), that's when they're ostracized.
In contrast, I think the Vancouver, Montreal, and Toronto markets are laughed at because they fan the flames and are seen as actively harming the team with the narratives spun. Seeing the Pettersson-Miller situation blow up the way it has, even with it being in no small part due to national media to be fair... IMO it's not a ridiculous view.
For example, within hockey circles here there was a widely known spat between Draisaitl and Nurse a few years back. Lots of speculation on what caused it (lol, Google it), but it never made it out into national media. Not like the Oilers are irrelevant leaguewide (like the Flames, Jets, or Sens)... local media just didn't give it any air time whatsoever. That's gotta be a good thing?
Having the 80's OBC so directly entrenched in the franchise obviously helps - guys like Spector and Staples have been buddy-buddy for decades with the Keith Gretzky's of the world - as does having guys like Bowman, Holland and Chiarelli as GM over a combative Gillis-type. And then add in Canadian star players vs European/Americans ones, and it's a perfect recipe for a shield from criticism from the broader national media.
Tbh, I wish local media in Vancouver could've lost their minds like this at the start of the 2011 playoffs. And lost in the local gloating/laughing around McDavid getting suspended and obviously not missing Myers for three games - many seem to gloss over that three games for the crosscheck on Bouchard is a ridiculous suspension. Jacob Trouba made that same play every three games in New York and got fined at most. Canucks media should be throwing more of a hissy fit, IMO.