Speculation: Armchair GM 2024-25 Season, Craig Conroy's Can Do Calgary Flames

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
  • We're expeting server maintenance on March 3rd starting at midnight, there may be downtime during the work.
Fair, but the point would be that most of the time when a truly elite C is available, the cost is either nuts, or there's warts/risk.

I mean in reality, the cost of acquiring PLD from LA was literally nothing.
He'd be leading our team in scoring. Not that he'd actually be leading the team, I think with our low end offence he'd probably only have 30-35 points now.

The issue is also that albatross he's carrying around, and we have enough questionable ones right now :laugh:
 
Fair, but the point would be that most of the time when a truly elite C is available, the cost is either nuts, or there's warts/risk.
Of the 13 PPG centers over the last 3 years (min. games), just JT Miller and Jack Eichel have been traded. One had neck issues, the other has been traded 3x (he wasn't elite the first 2 times) and seems to have some issues getting along with teammates.
 
Last edited:
I mean in reality, the cost of acquiring PLD from LA was literally nothing.
He'd be leading our team in scoring. Not that he'd actually be leading the team, I think with our low end offence he'd probably only have 30-35 points now.

The issue is also that albatross he's carrying around, and we have enough questionable ones right now :laugh:

Also fair, I was thinking more the cost that Winnipeg and LA paid for him. Washington got him for nothing because of the warts.
 
If that's the case, let's get it done. Did the team learn nothing from Monahan?
It's not just up to the team. If a doctor tells a player that their injury won't get worse and they want to play, teh team won't stop them because the player would get the NHLPA involved and it'd turn into a shit storm. That doesn't even factor in the optics with future free agents, they won't like that a player is being told they can't play when the player says they can.

This isn't a Flames problem, it's a hockey culture problem because they want to be seen as warriors by playing through pain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zirakzigil and Rubi
It's not just up to the team. If a doctor tells a player that their injury won't get worse and they want to play, teh team won't stop them because the player would get the NHLPA involved and it'd turn into a shit storm. That doesn't even factor in the optics with future free agents, they won't like that a player is being told they can't play when the player says they can.

This isn't a Flames problem, it's a hockey culture problem because they want to be seen as warriors by playing through pain.
The problem is that a long term injury to one part of the body can affect other parts of the body. Healthy parts of the body over compensating to take the load off of injured parts which leads to new injuries.
Teams need to be proactivity be about this sort of thing in order to protect the overall long term health of the player.. f*** the NHLPA.
 
Kirby Dach out again with knee injury... Has missed nearly 3 years in 5-6 years.


24 year old, RHS center, how about cheeky 4th rounder for him? He should recover before season starts.... Worth experiment?
 
The problem is that a long term injury to one part of the body can affect other parts of the body. Healthy parts of the body over compensating to take the load off of injured parts which leads to new injuries.
Teams need to be proactivity be about this sort of thing in order to protect the overall long term health of the player.. f*** the NHLPA.
You can't protect someone who doesn't want protecting
 
Kirby Dach out again with knee injury... Has missed nearly 3 years in 5-6 years.


24 year old, RHS center, how about cheeky 4th rounder for him? He should recover before season starts.... Worth experiment?

Not sure he’s worth the gamble. Which really is too bad, because he’s a great player when healthy.
 
Kirby Dach out again with knee injury... Has missed nearly 3 years in 5-6 years.


24 year old, RHS center, how about cheeky 4th rounder for him? He should recover before season starts.... Worth experiment?

I dunno if he's even salvageable at this point but if the price is right I'd be ok with it. In a contract year next season so he could be motivated. I know Habs fans are sick of him.

Tempting because he could be our very own reverse Sean Monahan ;)
 
Klapka is an impact player with the Wranglers yet they've scratched him the last 4 games consecutively now with Calgary. He'd look good in the lineup against Florida is all I'm saying.
 
They can't make Sharangovich get surgery if he needs it but they sure can make him a regular healthy scratch if his on ice performance sucks. Which it very obviously does. If that was the case it'd be classic Flames - keep the poorly performing veteran in the lineup because reasons while in the meantime, also screwing over perfectly adequate prospects in the minors like Kerins or Stromgren from getting some valuable experience.

That being said, I kind of doubt this injury related. He had 8 points in first 26 games, then 14 points in 22 games before the break. Now he's back to looking like the Sharangovich that started the season. No, this seems more like getting a big contract and then coasting issue. Or possible a confidence issue.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad