Are the Sabres better off without Skinner?

Are the Sabres better without Skinner?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 53 57.6%
  • No.

    Votes: 39 42.4%

  • Total voters
    92

LEAFANFORLIFE23

Registered User
Jun 17, 2010
47,113
15,734
No because they did not replace him with a better player.

Jason Zucker is not better than Jeff Skinner.

Jeff Skinner is not the reason they missed the playoffs for 13 straight years
 

sr edler

gold is not reality
Mar 20, 2010
12,084
6,558
As for Kessel being mentioned up thread, he scored over a PPG over three straight seasons in Toronto and even made the playoffs there once as the standout player on his team, so I don't really buy that comparison.

Histrionic Leafs fans being upset he couldn't take them to the promised land is not relevant to anything really.
 
  • Like
Reactions: norrisnick

tarheelhockey

Offside Review Specialist
Feb 12, 2010
86,196
142,342
Bojangles Parking Lot
As for Kessel being mentioned up thread, he scored over a PPG over three straight seasons in Toronto and even made the playoffs there once as the standout player on his team, so I don't really buy that comparison.

Histrionic Leafs fans being upset he couldn't take them to the promised land is not relevant to anything really.

Kessel was absolutely raked over the coals for his entire career as an “empty calories” one-way shooter on awkwardly-constructed Boston and Toronto teams. Then he went to Pittsburgh and Vegas, and suddenly his skills were valuable to winning Stanley Cups.

It’s a narrative that gets attached to certain wingers. Hell, at one point it was common on here to see people suggest that Ovechkin was a net negative for trying to win hockey games. A Cup ring ends that debate every time, which is just a dumb dynamic in hockey analysis.
 

BB79

Registered User
Apr 30, 2011
5,434
6,425
We'll see, but I think Skinner will be better off in Edmonton than he was with the Sabres. Playing in the shadow of McDri should take some pressure off him. I'll miss his epically bad goal songs in Buffalo though
 

Three On Zero

HF Designated Parking Instructor
Sponsor
Oct 9, 2012
31,934
30,848
We'll see, but I think Skinner will be better off in Edmonton than he was with the Sabres. Playing in the shadow of McDri should take some pressure off him. I'll miss his epically bad goal songs in Buffalo though
He’s been a complete ghost so far (I know I know, it’s only preseason)
 

sr edler

gold is not reality
Mar 20, 2010
12,084
6,558
Kessel was absolutely raked over the coals for his entire career as an “empty calories” one-way shooter on awkwardly-constructed Boston and Toronto teams. Then he went to Pittsburgh and Vegas, and suddenly his skills were valuable to winning Stanley Cups.

It’s a narrative that gets attached to certain wingers. Hell, at one point it was common on here to see people suggest that Ovechkin was a net negative for trying to win hockey games. A Cup ring ends that debate every time, which is just a dumb dynamic in hockey analysis.

Kessel played 4 games with Vegas that run logging 4th line minutes, so if people bring that up as some kind of feather in his cap, that would be weird.

People say a lot of dumb things on this board, which a lot of times makes it an insufferable place. Still doesn't make Kessel and Skinner comparable players ability wise. Kessel (while in Toronto) could really bury down on the wing and force the play north–south in a way Skinner never did.

People now talk about how great Skinner will look with McDavid. Kessel during Pittsburgh's back-to-back championships drove a line of his own with Bonino and Hagelin.
 

SensontheRush

Never said it was Sunshine
Apr 27, 2010
4,907
2,853
Ottawa
People love to call these guys "empty calories" until they go out to a well constructed team and their offense helps that team win a Cup.. but then that also doesn't count because it wasn't "their" team or something. Le Centre Master Race or something.
Who are you referring to exactly? Are you putting your chips on the table regarding Skinner going to EDM?
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad