Player Discussion: - Anthony Cirelli | Page 32 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

Player Discussion: Anthony Cirelli

It's so hilariously stupid the way people refer to this guy as a 3rd line C. Career high in goals, assists, points, Selke nomination and you still have some clowns trying to discredit how good he is. Battled through injuries too.

Excellent hockey player to anybody with a set of eyes, and one of the best 2 way C's in the game. Well deserved nomination. Contract is a steal. I hope those who disrespected this player over the years recognize their foolishness in due time.
 
Selke nomination today. Value high, no trade protection...
Isles fan coming in peace to see if you guys would have any interest in something around Dobson/Cirelli. My thinking as an outsider is that Geekie would slide to center, and Dobson would play with Hedman which would be lethal. This trade would be assuming a negotiated contract with Dobson

Would obviously love to talk about Howard as well but first wanted to see if there's any in dealing Cirelli for a top4 RD
 
Isles fan coming in peace to see if you guys would have any interest in something around Dobson/Cirelli. My thinking as an outsider is that Geekie would slide to center, and Dobson would play with Hedman which would be lethal. This trade would be assuming a negotiated contract with Dobson

Would obviously love to talk about Howard as well but first wanted to see if there's any in dealing Cirelli for a top4 RD
With a new contract in place for Dobson (what's the ballpark on his new expected AAV? 7ish?), I'd personally be very interested in this.
 
With a new contract in place for Dobson (what's the ballpark on his new expected AAV? 7ish?), I'd personally be very interested in this.
Probably more like 8.75, but maybe the tax advantage stuff gets it to 8.5. Could you see something around Cirelli and Howard for Dobson?
 
With a new contract in place for Dobson (what's the ballpark on his new expected AAV? 7ish?), I'd personally be very interested in this.
Cirelli for Dobson, no thanks. Dobson is likely getting a massive contract, so making this trade not only doesn't save Tampa any cap space (only hinders it further) and leaves them with a massive hole at 2C that they now can't fill with anyone meaningful and address the other spots that need attention.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peacefool


This is Cirelli's highest finish in Selke voting. Cirelli, who has received votes every season since 2019, also finished 4th (2020), 5th (2022), and 11th (2019)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peacefool
Personally think Hagel deserved more selke votes than cirelli won’t complain about having 2 forwards in the top 10 tho
 
It's so hilariously stupid the way people refer to this guy as a 3rd line C. Career high in goals, assists, points, Selke nomination and you still have some clowns trying to discredit how good he is. Battled through injuries too.

Excellent hockey player to anybody with a set of eyes, and one of the best 2 way C's in the game. Well deserved nomination. Contract is a steal. I hope those who disrespected this player over the years recognize their foolishness in due time.
Career highs? What are they? How many Goals did he score? 27, 20 that is the last two years. How about Assists? 32, 25 Points? 59, 45. PP? Goals 3, 3 Assists? 4,2, In 80 games.

What does the Selke Award reward?? Top DEFENSIVE F.

Kills penalties. Scores Goals, no real PP production. Defensive forward. 3rd line... Top 3rd line guy. I will go low 2nd, maybe. He just doesn't elevate enough. He is a support guy.

Why are you making him something he isn't? He is 2018 Yanni Gourde (64, 48 points), role player

He is not core... Should not be paid as core.
 
I would be shocked if he ever comes even close to winning it. Barkov probably has it for the next few years if he stays healthy as he's at least as good defensively as Cirelli (probably better) and million times the offensive player. If not Barkov, then someone else like Reinhart who is much better offensively than Cirelli.
 
Crazy that Point got two votes.
Blind voters confirmed. Point has done a complete 180 in our end the last two seasons. He got absolutely ass blasted against Florida last year. Him and Dumba puck watched shit left and right down the stretch and into the playoffs. Extremely disappointing because he has it in him to be more than serviceable as the defensive tasked center with higher upside/capabilities for offense. It actually sucks because he'd make Cirelli expendable and we could grab a more offensive minded, bigger center.

I really hope JBB does something about 2RW because rolling out the same top six is ludicrous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zwui21 and Hoek

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad