Very true. IMHO Cutter has a little more upside in terms of long term value to our rebuild, mainly due to his combo of size and high end shot that are severely lacking in our system. We need more high end players that can push some weight around when needed.
I guess I don't value the draft pick as much as some, even if it's a high 2nd. The chance of that pick becoming a high end NHL player is so low and so far away that it's worth the toss in.
People are looking for NHL'ers with 2nd round picks, not high end NHL'ers. Of course, there are some exceptions, but the ability to grab a top-4D or middle-6 forward has tremendous value to a team, especially when thinking about NHL depth.
We seem to be quite good at drafting d-men and goalies in the 2nd round. Here are a few drafted in the 2nd round: G Gibson in 2011, C Karlsson in 2011, LD Pettersson in 2014, RD Montour in 2014, LD LaCombe in 2019, LD Zellweger in 2021, RD Luneau in 2022, and Clara in 2023. Gibby was a star for a while. We've traded some d-men drafted for NHL forwards. For example, b/c the Ducks were good at drafting defensemen that they were able to package away other d-men in the Kesler trade. Vatanen, a 4th round pick, helped net us top-6F Rico. Currently, LaCombe, Zellweger, and Luneau are filling up or going to fill up our NHL roster.
The point is to have as many darts as possible b/c the draft after the top-10 it is a lottery. The further away from the top-10, the worse the chances of hitting an NHL player becomes. A high 2nd round pick has tremendous value. In this past draft, we selected Pettersson #35 in the 2nd round, but I really wanted RD Badinka. Badindka went one pick ahead of us. You know the Ducks and drafting defensemen are a thing.
As for acquiring Cutter, Verbeek seems to be loading up the forward group. We have five top-10 drafted forwards (Z, Mac, Cutter, Carlsson, and Sennecke) to only one top-10 drafted defensemen (Minty). I have no idea if this will pan out, but I'll cheer on success b/c that is what fans do.