Gaborik > Amonte
Gabbie was more talented at skating (mobility to change directions, accelerate, pivot) and stickhandling, and creativity and if it wasn't for injuries, he'd have some 50-goal seasons.
Amonte was more of an up-down winger, like a less speedy Gartner, and had a hard shot, played a lot of full seasons and maximized his production. His ceiling was lower and he reached it.
Gabbie easily led the Kings in playoff goals in their 2014 Stanley Cup championship postseason. He was a 2nd team all star with the Rags in 2012 (it was the only time in his 17-year career that he played a full 82-game season).
Gabbie also has constantly produced for Slovakia against much better teams in the world championships and Olympics.
Amonte accomplished the same number of 40-goal seasons and one more 30-goal season, less than 100 more career assists (significantly less game winners). Amonte was on two teams that went on a conference final run and he didn't contribute much either time. He represented USA in international competition but produced much less than Gabbie did, though Amonte was on the silver medal 2002 Olympic team and he was a secondary scorer (not top 5 on his team) in the 1996 World Cup victory. (I guess that is close to what Gabbie accomplished in the Stanley Cup, but not really.)