Elvis P
I got 9 lives, cat's eyes
All Time Draft - Seeding Poll. Please vote for the best 4 teams. You can vote for 4. The rosters are there > NFL: - ATD 1 - Rosters Only .
Last edited:
For me it was the receiving talent. I think when there's no designated spot for a KR or PR and no one else drafts a return specialist I'm not really sure how to evaluate Hester. You also had someone like Patrick Peterson who is more than good enough to handle return duties. I also don't really know how to judge the Sean Taylor pick given his career tragically cut short. I think someone like Miller works better in a 3-4, but I have some of that going on myself with my LBs. I think some think of it as more regimented where players can't play both, but if they're talented and versatile enough they can.New York Giants
QB - Dan Marino
RB - LaDanian Tomlinson
WR - Michael Irvin
WR - Ochocinco
WR - Devin Hester
TE - Jason Witten
LT - Gary Zimmerman
LG - Marshal Yanda
C - Dwight Stephenson
RG - Jahri Evans
RT - Dan Dierdorf
DE - Michael Strahan
DT - John Randle
DT- William Perry
DE - Richard Dent
OLB - Von Miller
MLB - Mike Singletary
OLB - Jason Taylor
CB - Emlin Tunnell
CB - Patrick Peterson
S - Paul Krause
S - Sean Taylor
How are there no votes for this team? Especially the defense... Perry doubles as a FB, can't kick or punt to Hester(while has Marino throwing to em).
I haven't decided or voted yet. The Fridge won no honors as a DL in his career and has 8 rushes for 5 yards. All of Hester's honors are for special teams. If you had drafted a better DL such as Lee Roy Selmon (before I drafted him) and a better WR than Hester such as Harold Carmichael or Art Powell the voters may have liked your team better.
I said Harold was better than Hester. Since you disagree with me that means you think Harold is a scrub.
Apparently you're my boss.QF? Please: wild card games. QFs means the voting is of no consequence. Two byes. Four wild card teams.