Yup. His difficulty came when he was moved to center. He primarily played with ROR and Landeskog.
Alexis Lafreniere disappointing season start? PART 2
- Thread starter Devil made me do it
- Start date
I watched him in junior, and especially the junior tournament.
I think he performed better than Matthews or Eichel at the same age.
Those performances were why he was so hyped prior to his draft.
Maybe he will just take longer to develop at the professional level? Or maybe he won't develop to that point at all?
KaseMeOutside
Based
- Oct 18, 2011
- 44,273
- 10,188
Stutzle may end up being the best player from that draft.
I wonder if the draft had have been held after the junior tournament, if Stutzle may have been picked higher?
Because he dominated, even while playing for a poor German team.
covfefe
Zoltan Poszar's Burner
- Feb 5, 2014
- 5,235
- 6,310
I should have clarified. His rookie year was lights out, his sophomore season - not so much, and the vultures started to circle. Some choice HF quotes about MacKinnon circa 2014:
Enigmatic Canadian.
The hype around him was ridiculous. Even some of the media guys thought he would be one of the high end scorers this year.
Nathan MacDaigle.
etc...etc.
It would only be concerning if they were from Calgary.
Last edited:
I don't. Matthews and Eichel both had clear skills that led to easy projections before you get into the fact they played more valuable positions. Eichel was fast with strength on the puck. Matthews was ridiculously strong on the puck and has an elite shot. When you are talking about top kids its a combination of elite production and clear elite skills.
Part of the reason I believed in MacKinnon was his combo of ridiculous speed and strength. He could always create separation, it was about his mind catching up to his playstyle.
I think that's just sweet. Unlike unrelated adult men that take tattoos featuring their favorite NHL players, and those are plentiful.
Below is a quote on my thoughts on him from August 10th, 2020 (in a Wild board topic on if the lottery Balls happened to fall our way just for reference.)
"When you watch his full games, he also has some warts in terms of decision making and turnovers, he makes a lot of blind passes. His play at the WJC was incredible, but doesn't match up with some of his late in the season CHL play. I think he will be fine physically out of the gate but I think he would struggle at least initially playing an NHL game, or at least the Wild's style of play. Whatever they did to get Fiala up to speed would likely be of huge benefit to Laf if he does end up on this team, but I do think there will be more of a learning curve than the consensus seems to think for this player."
I think his WJC play was an absurd run that drastically inflated his scouting outlook, of course he had the regular season points to back up stat watcher perception, but even in those high point games, some of his weaknesses were apparent. I think he can develop into a very strong player, but I disagreed with the immediate impact hype that so many people had by labeling him a generational wing.
"When you watch his full games, he also has some warts in terms of decision making and turnovers, he makes a lot of blind passes. His play at the WJC was incredible, but doesn't match up with some of his late in the season CHL play. I think he will be fine physically out of the gate but I think he would struggle at least initially playing an NHL game, or at least the Wild's style of play. Whatever they did to get Fiala up to speed would likely be of huge benefit to Laf if he does end up on this team, but I do think there will be more of a learning curve than the consensus seems to think for this player."
I think his WJC play was an absurd run that drastically inflated his scouting outlook, of course he had the regular season points to back up stat watcher perception, but even in those high point games, some of his weaknesses were apparent. I think he can develop into a very strong player, but I disagreed with the immediate impact hype that so many people had by labeling him a generational wing.
Leksand
Registered User
Must be possible to analyze that proposition more systematically. Does anyone know of any such analysis?
BTW where is basic nhl player data that you can download and slice and dice available?
Leksand
Registered User
AlaBlueShirt
Registered User
- Mar 14, 2018
- 1,704
- 2,305
They come from literally different worlds. Alex grew up in the f***ing USSR and Russia.
Artorius Horus T
sincerety
Machinehead
HFNYR MVP
Yup. Moving to the US and not able to have his best friend (his sister) with him like she has been his whole life.
Alexis Lannister will be fine, just needs to get his sister over to the States.
Sky04
Registered User
- Jan 8, 2009
- 29,671
- 18,993
He won the Calder... even his Sophomore "slump" season is much better than what Lafreniere is producing.
He's below Jack Hughes right now, but there are many 1OA's who have had poor rookie seasons go on to be elite players but almost every single one of them had a great 2nd year. Next year is a big indicator for Lafreniere.
Coastal Kev
There will be "I told you so's" Bet on it
Kobe Armstrong
Registered User
- Jul 26, 2011
- 15,671
- 6,631
BlueBaron
Registered User
But the Habs might have sent him down knowing the insane pressure he'd be under.
He may have been more driven and inspired having a better season
Or maybe he'd have a nervous breakdown and quit hockey.
The minute you change the setting you can no longer be sure of the same result, especially the Habs in this instance.
MatthewBarnabysTears
Registered User
- Mar 18, 2013
- 2,579
- 575
Incredible, given that criteria, how much heat he’s taking off Kakko (who was basically hyped as a 1OA -quality pick).
NickyFotiu
NYR 2024 Cup Champs!
- Sep 29, 2011
- 15,796
- 7,539
I have been as worried about him as anyone but I'm starting to see more and more flashes of talent. Last night he made multiple good plays. He seems to be gaining confidence. Even though he was considered NHL size he is still a 19 year old rookie. There is 19 year old strength and then there is grown man Weber or Chara strength. They are not the same. Laf will get better as he gets stronger.
Sky04
Registered User
- Jan 8, 2009
- 29,671
- 18,993
None? Kakko is producing as one of if not the worst #2 overall forward in the last 25 years. Gotta go back to Andrei Zyuzin in 1996 to find someone weaker than Kakko over their first 2 seasons.
2019 is a really weak draft.
Zats Muccarello
Grinder
