#87 Sidney Crosby Milestone Thread - History will be made (1600 points)

[Dessloch]

Oof!

At least it puts to rest the accusations by members of certain fan base that the NHL are stealing goals and assists from their star player, which Crosby would have got to keep.

I was a bit surprised they changed it as its not exactly conclusive from the camera angles, but most likely they got it right. They do obviously put a lot of effort into this.

 

[Hockey Outsider]

At 1,400 points, Crosby is two behind Alex Ovechkin for 21st in league history. Only Mario Lemieux, Wayne Gretzky and Steve Yzerman reached 1,400 points with one franchise.

Plus Gordie Howe (1,809 pts with Detroit), Joe Sakic (1,641 with Colorado - including Quebec, it's two cities but one franchise), Ray Bourque (1,506 with Boston) and Stan Mikita (1,467 with Chicago).

 

[Hockey Outsider]

With 3 (secondary) assists, Crosby has reached 50 assists for the 9th time.

That's a milestone, right?

I think it counts. Only 24 other players have done this.

 

[Shrimper]

Would have had a shot at 2,000 points in his career.

Next milestones are;

20th - Dale Hawerchuk on 1409 points
19th - Doug Gilmor on 1414 points

He should get those this season. 18th - Adam Oates on 1420 is too far with 8 games left.

21st - Dale Hawerchuk on 891 assists
20th - Phil Housley on 894 assists

Crosby is on 886 assist

Playing the remaining 8 games would put him 197th all time.

39th - Pierre Turgeon on 515 goals
38th - Dale Hawerchuk on 518 goals

Crosby is on 514 goals.

23 - Doug Gilmour on 882 ESP
22 - Gilbert Perreault on 882 ESP
21 - Henri Richard on 883 ESP

Crosby on 881 ESP

2 assists last night. Tied with Henri Richard for ESP

 

[Hierso]

Will there ever be another player that reaches 1400 points under 1000 games played?

 

[tarheelhockey]

Just curious, what would it take for Crosby to surpass Lemieux as the greatest Penguin player?

Obviously not comparing him to Mario’s role as an owner and franchise savior, that’s a different thing. And not suggesting he’s a “better player”. But in terms of achievements as a Penguin player, what’s the boundary?

- He’s 320 points behind Mario for the franchise record, which certainly seems doable.
- He will almost certainly take the record for assists, though goals might be a challenge (he would need 175 more).
- Already has a large lead for franchise GP.
- Already building on his lead as the team’s longest tenured captain.
- Crosby leads Mario in Cups (3-2) and is tied in Conn Smythes (2-2).
- Mario still has the advantage in Harts (3-2), Rosses (6-2), goalscoring/Richards (3-2). Mario has one more season as a 1st All Star center.

If Crosby wins another Cup with a Conn Smythe attached, does that push him over the top? Or is this more about having another Hart season? Or is it about compiling the career totals? All of the above? Or is it just impossible for him to compete with Mario’s aura?

 

[george14]

Just curious, what would it take for Crosby to surpass Lemieux as the greatest Penguin player?

Obviously not comparing him to Mario’s role as an owner and franchise savior, that’s a different thing. And not suggesting he’s a “better player”. But in terms of achievements as a Penguin player, what’s the boundary?

- He’s 320 points behind Mario for the franchise record, which certainly seems doable.
- He will almost certainly take the record for assists, though goals might be a challenge (he would need 175 more).
- Already has a large lead for franchise GP.
- Already building on his lead as the team’s longest tenured captain.
- Crosby leads Mario in Cups (3-2) and is tied in Conn Smythes (2-2).
- Mario still has the advantage in Harts (3-2), Rosses (6-2), goalscoring/Richards (3-2). Mario has one more season as a 1st All Star center.

If Crosby wins another Cup with a Conn Smythe attached, does that push him over the top? Or is this more about having another Hart season? Or is it about compiling the career totals? All of the above? Or is it just impossible for him to compete with Mario’s aura?

Not sure that can ever happen due to the mythical status of Mario (no sarcasm). However, I think another Cup +Smythe would get the debates rolling. Sid takes care of himself and I could see him playing until 40, but injuries are always a concern. It really depends how much more hardware he collects.

I don't think MVP's matter nearly as much as Conn Smythe's because that means your team likely won the Cup. Different sport but I think Peyton Manning has 2 more MVP's than Tom Brady, but no one really cares and not many even know that? Playoff success is what resonates so I think Sid would need to have some more sustained playoff success.

 

[Roksta]

Will there ever be another player that reaches 1400 points under 1000 games played?

McDavid is on pace to do it in 985ish games but of course he has a good chance of slowing down until then

 

[Old Gregg]

At least it puts to rest the accusations by members of certain fan base that the NHL are stealing goals and assists from their star player, which Crosby would have got to keep.

I was a bit surprised they changed it as its not exactly conclusive from the camera angles, but most likely they got it right. They do obviously put a lot of effort into this.

Ya hard to tell from any video if Rackell touched the puck or not. Also wondering if Crosby touched the puck in front of the net the way he reacted.

 

[Dessloch]

With a 1+2 effort tonight Crosby has tied Ovechkin on the all time scoring list, can he pass him before Ovi strikes back?

Alex Ovechkin: 1405 points in 1269 games
Sidney Crosby: 1405 points in 1102 games

1 Wayne Gretzky 2,857
2 Jaromir Jagr 1,921
3 Mark Messier 1,887
4 Gordie Howe 1,850
5 Ron Francis 1,798
6 Marcel Dionne 1,771
7 Steve Yzerman 1,755
8 Mario Lemieux 1,723
9 Joe Sakic 1,641
10 Phil Esposito 1,590
11 Ray Bourque 1,579
12 Joe Thornton 1,538
13 Mark Recchi 1,533
14 Paul Coffey 1,531
15 Stan Mikita 1,467
16 Teemu Selanne 1,457
17 Bryan Trottier 1,425
18 Adam Oates 1,420
19 Doug Gilmour 1,414
20 Dale Hawerchuk 1,409
21 Alex Ovechkin 1,403
22 Sidney Crosby 1,403
23 Jari Kurri 1,398
24 Luc Robitaille 1,394
25 Brett Hull 1,391

 

[Dessloch]

 

[Dessloch]

 

[Dessloch]

 

[metalan2]

I honestly believe Sid will get to number two in all time scoring by the end of his career. He's playing eight more seasons.

 

[Gurglesons]

Just curious, what would it take for Crosby to surpass Lemieux as the greatest Penguin player?

Obviously not comparing him to Mario’s role as an owner and franchise savior, that’s a different thing. And not suggesting he’s a “better player”. But in terms of achievements as a Penguin player, what’s the boundary?

- He’s 320 points behind Mario for the franchise record, which certainly seems doable.
- He will almost certainly take the record for assists, though goals might be a challenge (he would need 175 more).
- Already has a large lead for franchise GP.
- Already building on his lead as the team’s longest tenured captain.
- Crosby leads Mario in Cups (3-2) and is tied in Conn Smythes (2-2).
- Mario still has the advantage in Harts (3-2), Rosses (6-2), goalscoring/Richards (3-2). Mario has one more season as a 1st All Star center.

If Crosby wins another Cup with a Conn Smythe attached, does that push him over the top? Or is this more about having another Hart season? Or is it about compiling the career totals? All of the above? Or is it just impossible for him to compete with Mario’s aura?

Sid is the better “performer” for PIT. Mario will never be below Sid tho from a legacy stance.

 

[The Grim Reaper]

Sid is the better “performer” for PIT. Mario will never be below Sid tho from a legacy stance.

Crosby could win two more Cups and Mario would still be ahead. Mario saved the Pens, Crosby just made them relevant again.

 

[Gurglesons]

Crosby could win two more Cups and Mario would still be ahead. Mario saved the Pens, Crosby just made them relevant again.

I heard Mario could f*** your wife.

 

[The Grim Reaper]

I heard Mario could f*** your wife.

So you know there's an old saying in Tennessee — I know it's in Texas, probably in Tennessee — that says, fool me once, shame on — shame on you. Fool me — you can't get fooled again.

 

[Dessloch]

 

[Dessloch]

 

[Dessloch]

 

[Dessloch]

 

[Dessloch]

With the game winner tonight Sidney Crosby has just tied Jaromir Jagr and Malkin for the Penguins GWG all time record. If only Mario would have 78 GWG as well, would have been cool.

 

[wetcoast]

Just curious, what would it take for Crosby to surpass Lemieux as the greatest Penguin player?

Obviously not comparing him to Mario’s role as an owner and franchise savior, that’s a different thing. And not suggesting he’s a “better player”. But in terms of achievements as a Penguin player, what’s the boundary?

- He’s 320 points behind Mario for the franchise record, which certainly seems doable.
- He will almost certainly take the record for assists, though goals might be a challenge (he would need 175 more).
- Already has a large lead for franchise GP.
- Already building on his lead as the team’s longest tenured captain.
- Crosby leads Mario in Cups (3-2) and is tied in Conn Smythes (2-2).
- Mario still has the advantage in Harts (3-2), Rosses (6-2), goalscoring/Richards (3-2). Mario has one more season as a 1st All Star center.

If Crosby wins another Cup with a Conn Smythe attached, does that push him over the top? Or is this more about having another Hart season? Or is it about compiling the career totals? All of the above? Or is it just impossible for him to compete with Mario’s aura?

I think it really depends on how far the Pens can go in the playoffs and how long Crosby keeps up his elite level of play like this year and if people can look past the video game numbers and pure offense.

But maybe injuries make it impossible for some people as it would come down to Crosby doing these things and then some people with an overall perspective maybe ranking him higher.

 

[nowhereman]

With a 1+2 effort tonight Crosby has tied Ovechkin on the all time scoring list, can he pass him before Ovi strikes back?

Alex Ovechkin: 1405 points in 1269 games
Sidney Crosby: 1405 points in 1102 games

1 Wayne Gretzky 2,857
2 Jaromir Jagr 1,921
3 Mark Messier 1,887
4 Gordie Howe 1,850
5 Ron Francis 1,798
6 Marcel Dionne 1,771
7 Steve Yzerman 1,755
8 Mario Lemieux 1,723
9 Joe Sakic 1,641
10 Phil Esposito 1,590
11 Ray Bourque 1,579
12 Joe Thornton 1,538
13 Mark Recchi 1,533
14 Paul Coffey 1,531
15 Stan Mikita 1,467
16 Teemu Selanne 1,457
17 Bryan Trottier 1,425
18 Adam Oates 1,420
19 Doug Gilmour 1,414
20 Dale Hawerchuk 1,409
21 Alex Ovechkin 1,403
22 Sidney Crosby 1,403
23 Jari Kurri 1,398
24 Luc Robitaille 1,394
25 Brett Hull 1,391

And if not for injuries, he's probably already in the top 10 and closing in on 2000 points by the end of his career. Just an incredible player.