3rd Annual Ranger Elimination Game

[PIM]

]Derick Brassard (20) -2 (18)
Ryan Callahan (24)
Carl Hagelin (22)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (34) +2 (36)
Anton Stralman (13)

Derick Brassard (18)
Ryan Callahan -1 (23)
Carl Hagelin -1 (21)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman +2 (15)

 

[Chief]

Derick Brassard (18)
Ryan Callahan -1 (23)
Carl Hagelin -1 (21)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman +2 (15)

Derick Brassard (18) - 2 = 16
Ryan Callahan (23) + 2 = 25
Carl Hagelin (21)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (15)

 

[haohmaru]

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (25) (+2) (27)
Carl Hagelin (21)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (15) -2 (13)

 

[Blue Blooded]

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (27) - (2) = (25)
Carl Hagelin (21)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Strålman (13) + (2) = (15)

 

[JohnC]

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (25) + (1) = (26)
Carl Hagelin (21)
Rick Nash (34) - (2) = (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Strålman (15) + (1) = (16)

 

[mulli25]

Derick Brassard (16) - 2 = (14)
Ryan Callahan (26)
Carl Hagelin (21)
Rick Nash (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Strålman (16) + 2 = (18)

 

[and 99 others]

Derick Brassard (16) - 2 = (14)
Ryan Callahan (26)
Carl Hagelin (21)
Rick Nash (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Strålman (16) + 2 = (18)

Derick Brassard (14)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (21)
Rick Nash (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (41)
Dan Girardi (22)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (16)

 

[Nonvolition]

Derick Brassard (14)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (21)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (16)

 

[Gingeroux28]

Derick Brassard (14)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (21)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (16)

Same vote as yesterday... well almost!

Derick Brassard (14)+2(16)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (21)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (16)-2(14)

 

[Thirty One]

Same vote as yesterday... well almost!

Derick Brassard (14)+2(16)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (21)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (16)-2(14)

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (21) + (2) = (23)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (14) - (2) = (12)

 

[JDs Straight Shot]

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (32)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (21) + (2) = (23)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (14) - (2) = (12)

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (32) + (2) = (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (12) - (2) = (10)

 

[Faxius]

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (32) + (2) = (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (12) - (2) = (10)

Derick Brassard (16) -2 = (14)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (10) + 2 = (12)

 

[Off Sides]

Derick Brassard (16) -2 = (14)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (10) + 2 = (12)

Derick Brassard (14) +2 = (16)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (12) -2= (10)

 

[vipernsx]

Derick Brassard (14) +2 = (16)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (12) -2= (10)

C'mon how is Stralman more Valuable than MDZ?

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (28)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (43)+2=45
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (36)
Anton Stralman (10)-2=8

 

[JohnC]

Why do people think this is about value?

 

[FultonReed]

Why do people think this is about value?

because it says this in the first post:

This is a player elimination game to determine the players that are the most favorite/valuable in the eyes of HFNYR. A player that reaches 0 points is eliminated.

anyway...

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (28) +1 (29)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (36) +1 (37)
Anton Stralman (8) -2 (6)

 

[JohnC]

Don't think it's been a about value since page 2

 

[Faxius]

because it says this in the first post

Also says favorite player, which basically means it's a popularity contest. I don't get why people get their panties all in a bunch.

 

[Thirty One]

because it says this in the first post:

What part of favorite/ do you not understand?

 

[Joey Bones]

because it says this in the first post:



anyway...

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (28) +1 (29)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (36) +1 (37)
Anton Stralman (8) -2 (6)

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (29)
Carl Hagelin (18)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (37)
Anton Stralman (8)

 

[Boruto]

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (29)
Carl Hagelin (18) + 2 = (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (37)
Anton Stralman (8) - 2 = (6)

 

[mti79]

Derick Brassard (16)
Ryan Callahan (29)
Carl Hagelin (18) + 2 = (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (37)
Anton Stralman (8) - 2 = (6)

Derick Brassard (16) -2 (14)
Ryan Callahan (29)
Carl Hagelin (20)+2 (22)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (37)
Anton Stralman (6)

 

[aufheben]

Derick Brassard (16) -2 (14)
Ryan Callahan (29)
Carl Hagelin (20)+2 (22)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (37)
Anton Stralman (6)

Derick Brassard (14)
Ryan Callahan (29)
Carl Hagelin (22) -2 (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (37)
Anton Stralman (6) +2 (8)

 

[Machinehead]

Derick Brassard (14)
Ryan Callahan (29)
Carl Hagelin (22) -2 (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23)
Marc Staal (37)
Anton Stralman (6) +2 (8)

Derick Brassard (14)
Ryan Callahan (29)
Carl Hagelin (20)
Rick Nash (34)
Derek Stepan (39)

Ryan McDonagh (45)
Dan Girardi (23) - 2 = 21
Marc Staal (37)
Anton Stralman (8) + 2 = 10

 

[Machinehead]

Anton, Anton, he's our man!! If he can do it, we'll #DumpDan!!